The Daily Caller

The Daily Caller

Liberal Ezra Klein and conservative George Will: Harry Reid wasn’t wrong

There’s nothing wrong with what Sen. Majority Leader Harry Reid (D-Nevada) said about President Barack Obama, two well-known media figures say.

Unlike some Republicans, who say Reid’s recent remarks are racially charged, or some Democrats, who say what Reid said was insensitive but not intentional, they say all Reid did was tell the truth.

Liberal Washington Post blogger Ezra Klein is one of them.

“I’m trying really hard to understand why Harry Reid’s comments about Barack Obama’s electability were offensive,” Klein wrote in his Monday morning blog post. “Do people seriously dispute that light-skinned African Americans have traditionally been more palatable to white Americans? We literally have studies on this subject.”

Klein wrote that while it’s “weird” Reid used the word “negro” in his reported statement, it “seems to have a lot more to do with age than with racial attitudes.” He dismissed any notion of Reid being a racist, writing that the majority leader was supportive of Obama’s candidacy early on and has spent the past year push the president’s agenda through Congress.

“If that’s what counts for racism these days, then America has come a long way,” he wrote.

Reid has apologized for the comments attributed to him about Obama’s race during the 2008 campaign in John Heilemann and Mark Halperin’s new book, “Game Change.” Since the excerpts have gone public, some Republicans – including RNC chairman Michael Steele – have called for the majority leader to step down.

Yesterday on ABC’s This Week, conservative columnist George Will — an unlikely ally for Reid — got into a spirited debate with Liz Cheney, the daughter of former Vice President Dick Cheney, asking “did [Reid] get it wrong? … Did he say anything false?”

“I don’t think there’s a scintilla of racism in what Harry Reid said. At long last, Harry Reid has said something that no one can disagree with, and he gets in trouble for it,” Will said.

  • Pingback: Tucker Carlson Launches New Website |

  • niccolomachiavelli

    I was hoping for more discourse concerning the issues of language that Mr. Reid brought up, maybe something contrasting the artistic and poetic use of American Black Vernacular to Ebonics. If you guys represent the Republican – Right POV why is it that you are focused only on the racial issue rather than the language issue?

  • anonnymouse

    What they mean is, American liberal-white-guilt over racism can’t really be expunged until we elect some gangsta-rap singer as president. Even then, the moral truncheon of “race-guilt” {as in, “only whites CAN be racist, and every white person IS a racist (whether they admit it or not)”} will still hang over the heads of those who want to judge people on their merits –skill, education, accomplishment– WITHOUT giving bonus points based on skin color or ethnicity of surname.

  • Pingback: Barack Obama says uproar over Harry Reid’s ‘Negro dialect’ comment makes ‘absolutely no sense’ | The Daily Caller |

  • conservativefire

    The main egregiousness of Reid’s comment is the fact that he assumes of the American people what he ostensibly believes of blacks. Those comments cannot come from anything else but a inherent and suppressed anti-black viewpoint that managed to slip out of his mouth.