The Daily Caller

The Daily Caller

You say you want a revolution?

Supporters of the Tea Party Movement say they are dedicated to the ideals and principles of the Founding Fathers. Wouldn’t it be ironic, then, if they succeeded in forcing from office a man who has shed as much blood for his country as any Patriot in the Revolutionary War?

That is exactly what might occur in Arizona, where Tea Party activists are considering whether to endorse former Rep. J.D. Hayworth over former POW and current Sen. John McCain in the state Republican primary on August 24th. The activists apparently are upset with McCain because, they say, he has a history of working across party lines on issues such as immigration and betrayed their conservative ideals by voting for the TARP bailout in 2008.

McCain clearly has a long record of bipartisanship, and has never been shy about putting his name on a Democratic bill if he thought it was in the public’s best interests. But criticizing him for being a big spender ignores the fact that he consistently ranks among the staunchest fiscal conservatives in the Senate, and is perhaps the person most responsible for today’s push to ban congressional earmarks. It also ignores the possibility that McCain, who holds a large but not insurmountable lead over Hayworth, may choose to run as an Independent if the Tea Partiers come out against him and his lead vanishes as a result.

For a number of reasons, that possibility is not as far-fetched as one would think.

For one thing, it suits McCain’s temperament, and would be in keeping with his reputation as a maverick, which for some reason he recently downplayed in an interview with Newsweek but, in fact, has admirably demonstrated throughout his career. It would also be consistent with the example set by his political ally in the Senate, Joe Lieberman, who ran and won as an Independent after being defeated by liberal Ned Lamont in the Connecticut Democratic primary in 2006.

Beyond this, running as an independent would be in keeping with the example set by McCain’s political hero, Theodore Roosevelt, who bolted the Republican Party when he was denied the GOP nomination in 1912 and ran for President on the Bull Moose ticket that year. Roosevelt lost his bid to return to the White House, but his decision to press on in the face of adversity no doubt holds some appeal for McCain, who has never been afraid to go it alone in pursuit of a cause in which he believes.

Of course, McCain wouldn’t be alone if he were to undertake such an effort. He has a group of longtime staff members who would be right by his side. In this regard, it should be noted that two of these staff members – his former Chief of Staff Mark Salter and his former strategist John Weaver – are currently working on Independent Tim Cahill’s campaign to become Governor of Massachusetts. If McCain needs guidance on how to run as a third party candidate, he would not have to look any further than these two loyalists and veteran political hands.

  • sunnyr

    I respect John McCain’s military record and think he is a Patriot. However, he is not a true conservative, IMO, and I think it’s time to replace him with new blood. I am hoping for John’s retirement notice after November 2.

  • xfiler93

    No doubt we would be better off with McCain if he had won, but he is not a conservative at all. More a moderate liberal really. I dont hate him, but his entire career has shown he is not conservative.

  • havesomesense

    Are you kidding, Lou? McCain is a war hero and so conservatives should forgive his betrayal of the principles he was elected to uphold? That’s not an opinion, it’s lunacy.

    John McCain has gotten, deserves to get and will continue to get the utmost respect for his compelling service to our nation. That does not entitle him to a permanent seat in the U.S. Senate irregardless of his performance. He first ran in the 80′s as a Reagan conservative, but has long since stopped living up to that standard and that’s what conservatives are tired of. He’s a progressive in favor of massive government (see TARP as one example) and liberal immigration policy and thankfully, come November, his time is up.

  • smamere

    THIS PRESENTS A FALSE CHOICE. BOTH CAN BE HONORABLE MEN, MCCAIN IS INDEED AN AMERICAN HERO. THE TEA PARTY GROUP SIMPLY PREFERS THE CONSERVATIVE HAYWORTH. MCCAIN IS LEFT LEANING(DARE I SAY PROGRESSIVE) ON A NUMBER OF ISSUES, FROM MY PERSPECTIVE. I VOTED FOR THE SENATOR IN THE LAST PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION BUT WOULD BE HARD PRESSED TO VOTE FOR HIM IN THE SENATE RACE.