The education debacle of the decade

The obvious answer would seem to be to expand OSP and “save” more kids, not shut it down and force 100 percent of DC students to be “let down.”

When Congress killed OSP, there was a national backlash.  Editorials in papers across the country denounced the decision.  Thousands of kids from several states rallied on Capitol Hill to save the program.  Black leaders gathered in an act of civil disobedience before the front doors of the Department of Education.  They pointed out that just about half of African-American and Latino students are graduating from high school today and the OSP students are almost completely African-American and Latino.

Even the DC public-school chancellor supported OSP and told Congress that the public schools would likely not be able to reabsorb the students and give them the same quality education.  The DC City Council went so far as to petition Arne Duncan to reverse his decision.

Duncan understands the importance of school choice.  He famously said that “my family has given up so much so that I could have the opportunity to serve; I didn’t want to try to save the country’s children and our educational system and jeopardize my own children’s education.”  So he chose to send his kids to public schools in Virginia rather than DC.

In fact, 38 percent of Congress chooses to send their kids to private schools.  That’s four times the national average.  A vote in the Senate to save OSP was defeated 58-39.  If only the Senators who exercise school choice themselves had voted in favor of OSP, the program would have been saved.

And so OSP will end.  Thankfully, the students currently enrolled will be able to continue through to graduation.  But with no new students allowed in the program, it will die through attrition.

I’ve had the pleasure of working with the OSP parents and kids for the last four years. And I’ve come to know many of them personally, and experience firsthand their reaction to the heartbreaking news.

Latasha Bennett’s son, for example, attends an excellent school on a scholarship and he’s doing great.  Her daughter was going to attend kindergarten at the same school, thanks to OSP.  And then Latasha got the letter from Arne Duncan stating that her daughter was being forced to leave the program.  Her son was safe, but her daughter was one of the 216.  Latasha cannot afford the school’s tuition and the charter schools were all filled up by the time Duncan’s rejection letter showed up.  So her daughter had no option but to attend the local public school, which has two-thirds of its students failing to meet basic benchmarks in math and reading.

In fact, 90 percent of the 216 kids shut out of OSP were reassigned to failing public schools.

It’s too late to save OSP.  But thankfully, elsewhere the tide is turning.  Two weeks ago a bi-partisan school choice bill was signed into law in Louisiana.  It comes on the heels of a similar program in Oklahoma and is the nation’s 20^th school choice program.

People will continue to have intelligent and respectful debates about school choice and education reform.  And whether we are liberal, conservative, libertarian or independent, we can all agree that special interest groups should not be able to force politicians to kill cost-effective programs that work.

It boils down to this:  Parents deserve the freedom to choose the schools that best meet their needs.  And every child, regardless of background, deserves a quality education.  We should not dash their hopes and their futures to appease the politically powerful.

Bob Ewing works on the Institute for Justice’s award-winning media team. His writings have been published by outlets including the Albuquerque Tribune, Baltimore Examiner, BigGovernment.com, Cleveland Plain Dealer, Fee.org and The Freeman. He has secured news coverage in outlets nationwide, including Air America, All Things Considered, The Atlantic, The Economist, Forbes, Fortune Small Business, Hannity & Colmes, Marketplace, Marginal Revolution, National Public Radio, National Law Journal, National Review, Reason Magazine, The Wall Street Journal, The Washington Post, U.S. News & World Report and USA Today.

He lives in Arlington, Va., and enjoys spending his free time running barefoot and rock climbing in West Virginia. He can be reached at bewing@ij.org.