Brad Womack returning to The Bachelor

Few Bachelor fans will ever forget the night Brad Womack broke not one, but two hearts, on the season 11 finale in 2007.

But now Womack is back to take another shot at finding love, it was announced during Dancing with the Stars Monday.

“At first I was skeptical,” Bachelor host Chris Harrison tells PEOPLE. “But the more I thought about it, the more I fell in love with the idea of him coming back, getting another shot.”