The Daily Caller

The Daily Caller

State of the Union no-show

WASHINGTON (AP) — When Supreme Court justices enter the House of Representatives in their black robes for the president’s next State of the Union address, Samuel Alito does not plan to be among them.

The justice said the annual speech to Congress has become very political and awkward for the justices, who he says are expected to sit “like the proverbial potted plant.”

Of course, Alito did not remain impassive at the most recent State of the Union speech by President Barack Obama. He reacted to Obama’s unusual rebuke of the court for its decision in a campaign finance case by shaking his head and mouthing the words “not true.”

The 60-year-old justice, an appointee of President George W. Bush, acknowledged with a smile that his colleagues “who are more disciplined refrain from manifesting any emotion or opinion whatsoever.”

Alito, answering questions following a speech Wednesday at the conservative Manhattan Institute in New York, also said, “Presidents will fake you out.” The institute provided an online video link to Alito’s talk and question-and-answer session.

The president will begin a sentence with an invocation of the country’s greatness, Alito said. If justices don’t jump up and applaud, “you look very unpatriotic,” he said.

But, Alito continued, then the president may finish the thought by adding “because we’re conducting a surge in Iraq or because we’re enacting health care reform.” Justices aren’t supposed to react to statements about policy or politics.

The better course, Alito said, is to follow the example of more experienced justices like Antonin Scalia, Clarence Thomas and the recently retired John Paul Stevens. None has attended in several years.

“So I doubt that I will be there in January,” Alito said.

At least one justice, Stephen Breyer, has said he was not bothered by Obama’s criticism and believes justices should attend so that viewers can see the three branches of government represented in the same room.

  • Sonny119

    Good for you Justice Alito, and I wish Chief Justice John G. Roberts, Justice Clarence Thomas, Justice Anthony Kennedy, and Justice Antonin Scalia, would all join Justice Alito, in doing the same, as the Supreme Court is not required to be at the State of the union anyways, but was always there as a courtesy to the President.
    Well, Obama has changed all that now, along with everything else in the Country. Obama has managed to insult, and divide the whole nation.
    It’s about time, someone from the Supreme Court, started fighting back, at the Vile, Disgusting, and Unprofessional, verbal attacks, from the Delusional Denial Liar-in-Chief himself, Obama..
    Obama is not only an embarrassment to the Nation as a whole, but he is without a doubt, the most repulsive, repugnant, vile, President in U.S. History, among other great attributes, like being a far leftwing Liberal Anti-American Socialist Marxist, Pro-Arab Islamic Muslim radical extremist sympathizer.

  • truebearing

    I think he should attend and show Obama the respect he deserves….moon him on national television!

    • gatortarian

      I’d just sit there and read a copy of the Constitution, or maybe Common Sense.

  • Pingback: Today’s Most Popular Stories 10.17.10 - FishbowlDC