Opinion

Media corruption averted, this time

Photo of Patrick Chisholm
Patrick Chisholm
Writer/Editor, PolicyDynamics.Org
  • See All Articles
  • Subscribe to RSS
  • Bio

      Patrick Chisholm

      Patrick D. Chisholm is a writer/editor whose articles have appeared in numerous publications including The Washington Post, The Wall Street Journal, USA Today, Baltimore Sun, Houston Chronicle, San Francisco Chronicle, National Review, and South China Morning Post. From 2002 through 2006 he was an opinion columnist for The Christian Science Monitor. He is creative director of <a href="http://www.accentance.com/">Accentance, Inc.</a>, a video production company in Chantilly, Virginia, and runs the website <a href="http://policydynamics.org/">PolicyDynamics.Org</a> which includes articles, a blog, and VideoViews. Prior to founding Accentance in 2001 he was managing editor at KCI Communications (a financial publishing company), a staff writer at International Executive Reports, and a foreign affairs analyst in the State Department's Office of Mexican Affairs. He graduated from American University’s School of International Service with an M.A. in international affairs/international economics, and from Colorado College with a B.A. in history.

When you read an opinion article, how can you be sure that the author of the article isn’t being paid by an undisclosed party with a vested interest in the topic? Same with other news reports that you read or watch: how can you be sure that a public relations firm didn’t pay the media outlet to run it?

You can’t be sure. But if you’re fairly trustful of our media, you’ll assume that the author came up with the opinions on his or her own. If, on the other hand, you get wind of authors being paid to write by undisclosed parties, your trust in our media will break down. Cynicism will rise. That’s bad for our free press and for society.

A recent incident reinforced that cynicism.

Earlier this month, cyber security blogger Christopher Soghoian exposed PR firm’s Burson-Marsteller attempt to gin up negative press about Google without disclosing that Facebook is funding the effort. In an email, Burson asked Soghoian to author an op-ed that would have been critical of Google. Burson then would have tried to have it published in major publications.

The email didn’t say whether Soghoian would ghostwrite the article, or byline it. But the implication is that Burson wanted Soghoian to byline it. The author of the email, John Mercurio, wrote, “I’m happy to help place the op-ed and assist in the drafting, if needed.” Given that Mercurio could have written it himself, it appears the only reason he would approach Soghoian would be to ask him to byline it.

That’s a gross breach of ethics. Burson should have had someone at Facebook byline it — or someone at Burson with full disclosure that Facebook is its client. Instead, by approaching Soghoian, it sought to cover up its real agenda and mislead readers into thinking that an independent, influential blogger was arguing the case.

The email exchange implied that Soghoian would be paid for such services.

To add insult to injury, Mr. Mercurio doesn’t come from a PR background but from a journalism background. He’s a “veteran political journalist” who’s been “covering the Washington political scene for nearly two decades.” Journalists should know better. Apparently, many of them these days don’t.

All journalists and public relations professionals need to periodically read and re-read the Society of Professional Journalists’ code of ethics and the Public Relations Society of America’s code of ethics.

Mercurio and his PR firm also should have learned from the 2005 revelations unearthed by USA Today through a Freedom of Information Act request. USA Today found that conservative columnist Armstrong Williams promoted the No Child Left Behind Act without disclosing that he was being paid to do so by PR firm Ketchum, Inc., and ultimately by Ketchum’s client, the Department of Education. As Edelman Public Relations’ CEO Richard Edelman wrote, “This kind of pay for play public relations takes us back in time to the days of the press agent who would drop off the new record album and $10 to the deejay. It makes our industry’s efforts to ‘clean up’ behavior in newly created PR markets such as China and Russia look decidedly ridiculous.”

Tribune Media Services ended its syndication contract with Williams, stating, “…. readers may well ask themselves if the views expressed in his columns are his own, or whether they have been purchased by a third party.”

If Mercurio willingly approached Soghoian with no qualms about what he was doing, then that would be disturbing. If Mercurio was pressured by his company to do so, had major ethical scruples, and did it anyway, that would be disturbing, too.

What someone — particularly a former journalist — working in a PR firm should do in such a situation is refuse to do it, or resign in protest.