The Daily Caller

The Daily Caller

Why The New York Times would not review my memoir

Photo of Douglas MacKinnon
Douglas MacKinnon
Author, Rolling Pennies in the Dark

I wanted to wait long enough after my memoir was published before I wrote this so as not to be accused of self-promotion. As I’ve just had another book published, I’m hoping this is an acceptable time period and explanation, as my new publisher clearly wants all of my promotion energy focused on the new novel and not my memoir.

That said, I felt it important to relate why (as I was told) The New York Times chose not to review my memoir entitled Rolling Pennies in the Dark, which was published in February by Simon & Schuster. The book highlights my growing up in abject poverty, being homeless a number of times, and some of my messages and solutions to poverty based on my real-life experiences.

Like any author nowadays, it was incumbent upon me to do as much outreach to the media as possible to try and create a bit of buzz for the memoir prior to publication. As I have worked with the national media off and on for years, I was fortunate enough to have a fairly substantial list of contacts and friends.

But a funny thing happened on the way to the outreach. When I contacted a friend who used to work at The New York Times to ask about the best avenues of approach with the paper, he said, “Don’t even bother.”

When I asked “Why?” he said, “Look, you are a conservative and a fairly well-known conservative at that. The solutions you offer in your book come from that conservative perspective and run counter to everything most everyone at The New York Times believes. As such, they are never going to review your book.”

I persisted and mentioned that many people were comparing my book to The Glass Castle by Jeannette Walls, which was glowingly reviewed in The New York Times and went on to be one of the bestselling memoirs of all time.

“Doesn’t matter,” he replied. “Because of her work for MSNBC and other outlets, The New York Times perceived her as one of them and so they were happy to review her book. You, my friend, are clearly not one of them, so just forget about The Times.”

I did not forget and made sure Simon & Schuster sent The New York Times a review copy. We heard nothing back.

After publication, even the left-leaning Publishers Weekly and Kirkus reviewed my memoir, with Publishers Weekly giving it an exceptionally strong review.

Overall, the book has done fairly well and has hovered at or near number one on two of Amazon’s sub-category bestseller lists since publication.

After letting some time go by and with my friend’s cautionary remarks still bouncing around in my head, I emailed Sam Tanenhaus, the editor of The New York Times Book Review, to make him aware of my friend’s warning.

To his great credit, Mr. Tanenhaus got back to me right away, albeit with the expected explanation that my friend was “mistaken and misinformed.” He was also kind enough to say that if my publisher submitted a book for review, it would be evaluated based on “its interest to our readers.”

After that response, I had Simon & Schuster re-send the now-published book to the attention of Mr. Tanenhaus. As of today, when I turn my ears toward the New York Times building, I still only hear the sound of crickets.