Black Rifles & Tactical Guns

The New Bang for the Buck

By Karen Mehall, American Hunter 

The Oklahoma wind slapped my face hard when I stepped from the light of the truck into darkness but it didn’t slow me down—I wanted to get to my stand. This was my first hunt with an AR-15, and I felt like a little [email protected]##.

“Remember, deer already will be in the trees on the field’s edge waiting for the feeder to go off,” said my guide, Clint Seaman. “Rack one into the chamber quietly.”

Clint was right. When the first pink streaks filtered across the sky, I saw does awaiting the breakfast bell. I like this spot, I thought. Eyes moving and brimming with tears, I hunkered down in the wind, swaying like a tumbleweed as I clutched my M&P-15.

I caught movement in the trees 30 yards to my left—a doe and a flash of antler. The doe entered the field, followed by the antlers—giant chocolate horns with thick, blunt, club-like tips. The doe stopped to feed while her sentry stood broadside at 70 yards. The deer had no idea I was there. I couldn’t believe the vision of the gift before me nor the ease with which I would receive it. I flipped the safety, put the crosshair on the buck and squeezed.


Where was the bang? My heart raced. The buck stared at me. How do I eject this cartridge—silently and without moving? The doe spooked then both deer ran across the field and disappeared.

The cartridge hadn’t fed properly during the gentle loading process moments earlier, so the round didn’t fire. Clearly, the AR-15 features a forward-assist button for good reason, but, wishing to be quiet before dawn, I hadn’t used it. I wished for an instant replay and a chance to slam that cartridge into the chamber. But there would be no do-over this morning—just as there are never any do-overs in hunting. I could have shed tears without help from the stinging wind as I frantically struggled to clear the action when the buck ran back across the field, grunting. Then he was gone. So much for any fantasy I had about an easy shot at a Booner buck. I was bad alright—so bad I let an opportunity-of-a-lifetime monster tease me twice then disappear for good.

Suddenly I felt the cold. It’s funny how much faster chilly temps register when no more bucks are in sight.

Over dinner at the Chain Ranch I shared my lesson. “We never even got that buck on the trail cams,” said Clint. “He must have been cruising through because of that hot doe.” My heads-up shiny penny was gone, but I asked to return to the same spot the next day. I guess I thought I deserved another chance.

The next morning I slammed that bolt carrier forward before daybreak ushered in a never-ending stream of deer. About 150 yards to my right I watched a buck approach. A look through the bino registered he was a 10-pointer. I snapped a quick photo and shouldered the gun. I watched him through the EOTech sight—so regal and elegant. Beautiful deer, I thought.


He ran 20 yards in the foot-high grass and dropped. My rifle and DRT (Dynamic Research Technologies) ammo sure did the job. I’d been blessed with seeing nice bucks twice in as many days.That evening I shot a doe then posed for a pic with my new friend Ned, the ranch’s pet steer. My buddy Paul Pluff was the only one in my group who hadn’t gotten a buck by the time I left camp, but when he scored he scored big, dropping a B&C buck the very next day. I marveled over the photo he texted, noting it was not the chocolate-horned Booner that gave me the slip.

That hunt occurred during the fall of 2010, though my first stint with an AR occurred 20 years earlier during my PR days while running the NRA National Matches press office at Camp Perry, Ohio. It was during the height of the semi-auto “ban-wagon,” when anti-gunners labeled ARs as so-called “assault rifles,” assuming that’s what “AR” stood for instead of ArmaLite, the company that designed the guns in 1957.Their assault was based solely on appearance, and ARs got a bad rap.

Public education was tricky for me. Most media had no clue what  they were demonizing, and those who did lied—banking on public confusion over the difference between automatic and semi-automatic guns. I explained that military guns in general are designed to be easy to understand and shoot so soldiers can be trained with them quickly and efficiently. I explained that about the only difference between the military’s M16 and its civilian counterpart, the AR-15, is the capability of the former for automatic fire, but that the latter can fire only in semi-automatic mode. I also explained that sure, an AR-15 looked different than Grandpa’s old .30-30 or Dad’s Winchester Model 70, but ARs, too, only fired one shot per pull of the trigger. If cosmetics alone could pull off miracles, I said I’d buy a Thoroughbred, hire a jockey and win the Kentucky Derby. The fact is, when they leave military service, countless veterans opt for AR-15s because it’s a design they already understand. And then there are countless civilians who just enjoy shooting and hunting with an AR.

In the name of education, I organized a National Matches media shooting event. After taking my turn alongside reporters on the firing line, I understood how effective the guns were in long-range matches and why they’d gained such traction in the civilian market. The rifle is accurate, lightweight and fun to shoot. I was sure my dad and my brother, Joe, would have fun with one. As a late-comer to hunting, I hit the woods with them that year, but decades passed before I had the chance to hunt with an AR. Thanks to my friend Paul Pluff, head of marketing at Smith & Wesson, and my old PR friends Bill Booth, Gary Guidice and Matt Rice of Oklahoma’s Blue Heron Communications, my initiation occurred in 2010. I had so much fun hunting with Smith & Wesson’s M&P-15 that I became hooked. And once I became a “seasoned” AR hunter, they all agreed I’d have to return to the Sooner State and hunt the Chain Ranch again sometime.