The 18 senators redrafting the Senate immigration bill tried to outbid each other Tuesday in claiming to protect American workers — including executives — against increased competition.
The bill already provides an array of protections to Americans workers, said Democratic Illinois Sen. Dick Durbin, one of the eight co-authors of the 867-page bill.
The bill demonstrates “our commitment as a nation of immigrants” and also boosts border protection, he said. “The third element, I think for everyone involved, is if there are jobs that are available, they will be offered first to Americans,” he said.
Democratic New York Sen. Chuck Schumer, the leading senator in the “Gang of Eight,” voted against several GOP measures that would have increased federal oversight of hiring decisions, but said the bill protects American workers.
“What we tried to do in our proposal is to find a balance” of economy-boosting benefits and worker protections, he said. “For low-skilled labor, we were tougher” in establishing protections.
Republican Alabama Sen. Jeff Sessions pushed for a measure that would have capped immigration at 1.2 million people per year. In concert with current law, the pending bill would provide work permits to 30 million people over the next ten years.
“Won’t that [inflow of] labor pull down wages, won’t that make it harder for Americans to get jobs, for their children to get jobs, for their grandchildren to get jobs?” asked Sessions.
“We are really not considering sufficiently what the right amount of immigration is for America,” he said.
But the measure was defeated 1 to 17, with Sessions’ GOP allies voting against his cap.
Republican South Carolina Sen. Lindsey Graham voted against Sessions’ measure, saying the country needs more workers to offset the accelerating retirement of the Baby Boom generation.
“A very good case can be made” that wages are reduced by immigrants, said Graham, who is part of the Gang of Eight. “I think wages have been suppressed up to a point, but … it is better that we bring people into our country than have the businesses close or leave” because of worker-shortages, he said.
Democratic Rhode Island Sen. Sheldon Whitehouse, however, persuaded his fellow senators on the Judiciary Committee to amend the bill so that mid-level executives can complain when their jobs are outsourced.
In local meet-and-greets with constituents, Whitehouse said, he’s met “fairly senior middle management people who get let go and then get replaced by folks who are from overseas, who are living in hotels, and who are brought into the office in buses.”
“They need a place to complain so we have a way to go after that kind of misbehavior,” he told The Daily Caller after the May 14 markup session.
Schumer said the bill would protect workers by reducing competition from illegal immigrants. “The idea that people who are here illegally don’t depress wages more than people who are here legally, defies my belief,” he said.