The Daily Caller

The Daily Caller
Russian President Vladimir Putin arrives for a meeting with Ben van Beurden, chief executive officer of Royal Dutch Shell, at the Novo-Ogaryovo state residence outside Moscow April 18, 2014. REUTERS/Alexei Druzhinin/RIA Novosti/Kremlin Russian President Vladimir Putin arrives for a meeting with Ben van Beurden, chief executive officer of Royal Dutch Shell, at the Novo-Ogaryovo state residence outside Moscow April 18, 2014. REUTERS/Alexei Druzhinin/RIA Novosti/Kremlin  

Tunnelling Wealth To Vladimir Putin

Photo of Paul Gregory
Paul Gregory
Research Fellow, Hoover Institution

As Vladimir Putin goes over the top (allowing kidnapping of OSCE observers in Ukraine) and his disregard for Barack Obama becomes more obvious (putting Edward Snowden on his annual talkathon), the media has become more curious about Putin’s secret wealth. The New York Times’s 2,000-word feature, “Sanctions Revive Search for Secret Putin Fortune,” covers what we know about Putin’s hidden wealth, estimates of which range from 10 to 70 billion dollars.

In the first round of sanctions announced on March 6, the Department of Treasury targeted, among others, Gennady Timchenko, one of the two founders of the Gunvor commodities trading company and currently the world’s sixty-first most wealthy individual. Timchenko is a citizen of Finland, who lives in Switzerland.

In its sanctions announcement, the treasury department asserted that “Putin has investments in Gunvor and may have access to Gunvor funds.” The definitive tone of this short statement creates the impression that the treasury knows what it is talking about.

I proposed sanctioning Timchenko in a Forbes blog dated March 3, arguing that as a Finnish citizen he could be questioned in Finnish or European courts. This post elicited an almost immediate e-mail response from a Seth Pietras, who identifies himself as Corporate Affairs Director, Gunvor Group. Mr. Pietras stated he wanted to “offer some clarity on the matter” and to assure me that any rumor about Russian President Putin “hiding” wealth in Gunvor, “has no basis in reality.”

Pietras puts forward Gunvor’s history of low profits as proof that rumors of Putin’s financial interest in the company “have no basis in reality.” He cites as a “mathematical improbability” that Putin could accumulate “significant hidden wealth” from a company that “over its entire 14 year history has only generated a total, aggregate net profit of approximately USD $4 billion.” Given Gunvor’s investment and liquidity requirements, “there is nothing to hide.”

Gunvor, like many commodities traders, is privately held and has limited reporting requirements, but its offering of bonds on the Singapore exchange brought forth a preliminary offering circular that describes the company’s operations and its financial results.

The circular shows 2012 gross revenue of $94,146 million, a cost of sales of $92,398 million, and a gross profit of $747 million. Pietras is correct: Gunvor’s profit rate is a low eight tenths of one percent. Indeed, Gunvor nets precious little from its almost one hundred billion in revenue.

The circular also lists under assets Gunvor’s fifty percent interest in the Novorossiysk Fuel Oil Terminal. For those who do not know, the Novorossiysk terminal is the epicenter, through which the bulk of Russian oil exports flow after transiting the Transnet monopoly pipeline. He who controls Novorossiysk, in effect, controls Russian oil. It is a fair question to ask how a company born in 2000 managed to obtain half ownership of the choke point of Russian oil exports?

Anyone familiar with Mafia casino skimming, kickbacks on government construction projects, or off-the-books work understands that revenue and cost streams of nearly $100 billion conducted through a long chain of producers, intermediaries, traders, and final users offers a cornucopia of opportunities for skimming, kickbacks, and other types of corruption, which can be concealed from prying eyes.