The Most Powerful Argument You’ll Ever See for Staying in the Stock Market

Money Morning Contributor
Font Size:

My good friend Dennis, a Seattle-based TV studio producer, pulled me aside Monday after I’d wrapped up Monday’s appearance on FOX Business Network‘s “Varney & Co.” to voice a sentiment I hear a lot these days:

…I’m almost 60 and scared to death by what’s happening today – terrorists, a looming rate hike, slowing earnings, global growth cratering.

He rattled off half a dozen items bugging him, counting each on his fingers. Then he leaned in and quietly said…

…it makes me want to sell it all.

If you’re like Dennis, you’re not alone.

Investors pulled almost $40 billion from the stock market last quarter alone, according to Morningstar. That’s nearly 50% of everything taken out for all of 2015.

But here’s the thing… no matter how grim the global situation is or even becomes, indiscriminately selling is exactly what you don’t want to do.

It’s one of the worst possible decisions any investor can make and, ultimately, one that will cost investors billions in lost profits.

Today we’re going to talk about why and, because this is not a simple subject, I’m going to prove it to you, too.

Roller Coaster Stock Markets DON’T Have to Mean Roller Coaster Returns

We’ve talked many times about the importance of buying low and selling high. It’s the path to higher returns.

So why is it that so many investors get it wrong?

The answer comes down to a phenomenon known as “recency bias.” That’s what they call it when investors make decisions based on what they see in the rear-view mirror. If the markets are going up, they buy. If they’re going down, they sell.

Simply put, they base their expectations for what’s next on what just happened. That’s like trying to bet which t-shirt a three-year-old will wear tomorrow, and about as successful.

In fact, there’s very little correlation between past stock market returns and actual future returns.

Moreover, YiLi Chien, a senior economist for the St. Louis Fed, studied equity markets from 1984 to 2012 and found that the correlation between past market behavior is almost perfectly negative over time.

That jives with the DALBAR data we’ve already covered here in Total Wealth showing that individual investors who try to time the markets wind up damning themselves to terrible returns by falling far behind over time – nearly 200% behind, in fact.

People tell me frequently that they don’t care. They want to sell anyway because they can afford to wait.

Respectfully, no they can’t.

Chien’s study also shows individual investors trying to second-guess the markets may fall behind by nearly 40% in only seven years. Extrapolate that out 20 years and you’re talking about potentially missing out on 300% to 500% or more in cumulative gains.

Again, the flight to safety is a powerful incentive. I get it, but the stock market has a long-term upward bias that we’ve talked about many times. Sure, it may have some short-term speed bumps, but over time the constantly increasing amount of capital chasing fewer quality stocks ensures higher prices. Over a day, a week, a year… it really doesn’t matter much.

Short-term instability inevitably gives way to higher prices over time.


Now, just for the sake of argument, let’s assume you give in and you do sell. If you need the money, that’s fine. There’s nothing wrong with that.

However, what happens is most investors who bail inadvertently create a far worse problem – they find themselves needing to get back in.

Given that they timed things poorly on the way out, odds are good they’ll time things poorly on the way in as well. So you get taken to the cleaners twice.

Ergo, pulling your money out of the markets may feel good, but chances are exceptionally high you’ll miss out on the rebound and ALL the opportunity that comes with it.

You may agree with me totally. You may not. I have no way of knowing. What I do have, however, is a way of proving to you just how tough this actually can be courtesy of this handy market simulation from Quartz that uses a random 10-year history of the S&P 500 to drive the point home.

Try it a few times and let me know how you do in the comments section. My entire office did and not one person outperformed the markets despite some people trying three, four, even five times.

I think the game is one of the most powerful arguments for staying in the markets I’ve ever seen. It’s certainly among the most persuasive.

Speaking of which, holiday-shortened weeks like last week are almost always volatile. The volume thins down, spreads widen, and there’s simply not as much going on. For the most part, that’s normal.

What catches most people by surprise is what this means for prices.

Effectively, the combination of low volume and wide spreads means that any small price move is magnified. The headlines, of course, don’t understand the subtlety, so any move risks being blown out of proportion. Up or down… it really doesn’t matter.

The key to navigating this kind of trading is twofold: 1) you’ve got to take a deep breath and keep perspective, and 2) you’ve got to be prepared ahead of time.

We’ve been doing both here at Total Wealth for months now.

We’re confining our money to the six “Unstoppable Trends” we follow…

We’re investing only in the best companies making must-have products tapped into those trends…

And we’re controlling risk like a hawk by using dips as buying opportunities and selling into strength when there are big gains to be harvested and/or capital to be protected…

As always, I’ll be watching things carefully and will, of course, be in touch immediately if there’s something that merits your undivided attention.

Follow us on Twitter @moneymorning or like us on Facebook.

Editor’s Note: The Dow doubled more than five times over the last century, making far-sightedness hugely rewarding for long-term investors – but Keith has found a company he believes will double repeatedly within the next few years. This small-cap robotics company is poised to ride a 700% boom in spending for the Unstoppable Trend Keith uncovered for his Total Wealth readers – and though it outperformed the markets by 4:1 in the first year of his recommending it, the rally’s still not over. For a full and free report on the company, including stock ticker, sign up for Total Wealth here – it’s free!

About Money Morning: Money Morning gives you access to a team of ten market experts with more than 250 years of combined investing experience – for free. Our experts – who have appeared on FOXBusiness, CNBC, NPR, and BloombergTV – deliver daily investing tips and stock picks, provide analysis with actions to take, and answer your biggest market questions. Our goal is to help our millions of e-newsletter subscribers and visitors become smarter, more confident investors.To get full access to all Money Morning content, click here.

Disclaimer: © 2015 Money Morning and Money Map Press. All Rights Reserved. Protected by copyright of the United States and international treaties. Any reproduction, copying, or redistribution (electronic or otherwise, including the world wide web), of content from this webpage, in whole or in part, is strictly prohibited without the express written permission of Money Morning. 16 W. Madison St. Baltimore, MD, 21201.

Money Morning