NYC Factsheet: It’s A ‘Myth’ That Men Who Identify As Women Aren’t ‘Real Women’


Font Size:

According to a factsheet published by New York City’s Commission on Human Rights, it’s a “myth” that biological men who identify as women aren’t actually “real women.”

The commission published a “myths vs. facts” document on gender identity and expression after receiving a flurry of criticism over its transgender guidance that forces businesses to accommodate 31 different gender identities.

One of the “myths” listed is that “Transgender women are not ‘real’ women, and transgender men are not ‘real’ men.”

Next to that myth, the commission asserts the correct “fact”: “Gender identity is not based on one’s sex assigned at birth.” The implication is that one’s self-determined “gender identity” — rather than one’s biological makeup — is what makes a woman a woman.

Underneath the “myth” and “fact,” the commission offers an explanation of the issue.

“If someone’s gender identity is female, then that person is a woman – regardless of what her birth sex was – and she should be treated as a woman,” the document states. “Similarly, if someone’s gender identity is male, then that person is a man, and he should be treated as a man.”

The document also states that it’s a “myth” that, “The New York City Human Rights Law allows men to enter the women’s bathroom and vice versa.” The “fact” the commission offers to disprove that “myth” is “If an individual identifies as a man, he is not permitted to use the women’s room.”

The document explains this by stating: “The NYCHRL allows individuals to use the bathroom that is consistent with their gender identity.”

The implication, again, is that one need only self-identify as a woman to be a woman.

The document also states that it’s a “myth” that: “If the clients/students/customers at an agency/school/business object to transgender people using the facility of their choice, the agency/school/business should change its policies to satisfy those objecting.”

The commission explains this “fact” by stating: “Agreeing to the unfounded fears and misconceptions around transgender inclusive policies is unlawful and perpetuates discrimination.”

The document goes on to say that, “The Commission can help covered entities educate their clients and customers about how inclusion creates a safer space for everyone.”

The commission offers “training” workshops for employers, business owners, and housing providers, who are invited to come so they can “know your obligations.” Each training workshop lasts approximately two hours.

The full “myths vs. facts” document can be read here.

Follow Peter Hasson on Twitter @PeterJHasson