Married Thirtysomething Teacher Traumatized Teen With ’11 Or 12′ Sex Frolics And A Naked Selfie, Cops Say

Williamson County Sheriffs Office

Font Size:

This week’s married thirtysomething English teacher busted for allegedly traumatizing a male teenager with either 11 or 12 sex romps is Nicole Marie Faires Andrews.

Andrews, 31, was a sixth-grade teacher — until last month — at Cedar Park Middle School in a quiet suburb of Austin, Texas, reports the Austin American-Statesman.

Romantic sparks flew between Andrews and her 16-year-old paramour after they met while she was moonlighting as a volunteer youth administrator at the Church at Canyon Creek, a Baptist church in Austin.

The unnamed teen, a student at Vandegrift High School (about eight miles down the road from Cedar Park Middle School) estimated that he had participated in 11 or perhaps 12 “sexual contact” frolics with Andrews, according to an affidavit obtained by the Statesman.

The teen also told investigators that Andrews sent him a naked photo of herself via social media.

The first sexual encounter between Andrews and the teen appears to have occurred early this summer.

Andrews is married to Dustin Andrews, a hunky fitness instructor and the co-owner of a CrossFit gym in the Austin area.

Nicole Marie Faires Andrews and Dustin Andrews have a young son together.

Dustin Andrews’s father, Damon Andrews, is the executive pastor at the Church at Canyon Creek — the same church where Nicole Marie Faires Andrews met the teen.

The senior pastor at the Church at Canyon Creek, Monty Watson, issued a statement calling for prayer.

“Our hearts go out to the victim and the family, and we ask for prayer for all involved,” Watson said, according to Austin NBC affiliate KXAN-TV. “We are working with the authorities and fully cooperating with this investigation.”

Back in October, when the investigation into Andrews began, the principal at Cedar Park Middle School sent a letter home to parents explaining that the teacher had been placed on administrative leave.

The principal, Sandra Stewart, has also assured parents that none of the 11 or 12 alleged sexual encounters occurred on any public school property in the area, according to KXAN.

Andrews resigned from her job as an English and language arts teacher in early November.

She began her brief teaching career at Cedar Park Middle School in the fall of 2015.

Deputies from the Williamson County Sheriff’s Office arrested Andrews on Dec. 12.

She faces charges of sexual assault of a child and improper relationship between an educator and student.

If convicted, Andrews could spend up to 20 years in prison.

Follow Eric on TwitterLike Eric on Facebook. Send story tips to