Satanic Temple Sues Arizona City Over Alleged Discrimination

Daily Caller News Foundation logo
Joshua Gill Religion Reporter
Font Size:

The Satanic Temple filed a lawsuit against Scottsdale, Ariz., on Friday over the city officials’ refusal to allow a satanic invocation before the city council.

Members of The Satanic Temple (TST) alleged that the Scottsdale city council actively sought to discriminate against satanists and to prevent non-Christian citizens from offering invocations before council meetings for the last eight years, according to a press release sent to The Daily Caller News Foundation.

The satanists’ legal action against the city council, after city officials allegedly rescinded an offer to have TST member Michelle Shortt, lead an invocation and replaced Shortt with a Baptist minister.

The temple claims in its lawsuit that Mayor Jim Lane said on his 2016 campaign website “In Scottsdale we’ve decided to keep our traditional invocations and we’ve decided to send this Satanist sideshow elsewhere.” The website is no longer active, but an archived snapshot of the site showed that it listed as an accomplishment that Lane “Helped stop a mockery of City hall invocations by halting a so-called ‘prayer’ by ‘Satanists.'”

The temple also submitted records of the council members’ emails as evidence of the alleged discrimination.

The press release states that Councilwoman Kathy Littlefield wrote in one email that she did “NOT want the Satanists” to offer an invocation. Littlefield’s email, which she sent to a citizen who expressed concern over the satanist invocation, in context reads, “Personally, I like having the prayers, do NOT want the Satanists, and I think this is taking equality too far. However, we are all sworn to uphold the law and cannot disobey it just because we find it undesirable and stupid.”

Email from Scottsdale Council Woman Kathy Littlefield to a concerned citizen about a Satanist invocation. (Public Record)

Email from Scottsdale Council Woman Kathy Littlefield to a concerned citizen about a Satanist invocation. (Public Record)

Local news outlet KVOA also reported that a councilman wrote in an email that “deliberations on the council should be ‘guided by God alone.'”

That councilman was David N. Smith, who actually wrote in his email to a concerned citizen that while he shared their sentiment that a satanist invocation was “a decision to worship evil,” their right to perform the invocation was protected by the Supreme Court’s interpretation of the First Amendment, no matter how absurd it seemed.

“I wish (an intend) my deliberations on Council to be blessed and guided by God alone. I genuinely appreciate your input,” Smith wrote.

Littlefield also stated that the council was, at the time, conferring with an attorney to discuss their options since, in her view, the satanists did not really seek to offer a prayer since they identify as atheists and don’t believe in any higher power. Later emails from the council members state that the satanists chose to postpone the invocation, which was scheduled for April 5, 2016.

Stuart de Haan, attorney for TST, told TheDCNF in an email that Shortt had to postpone the invocation as she was out-of-state on the initially proposed date. Shortt agreed to reschedule for July 6, 2016, but city leaders reneged on the offer in the interim.

“The city is not going to deviate from its long standing practice of having the invocation given only by representatives from institutions that have a substantial connection to the Scottsdale community. Therefore we are making other arrangements for the invocation to be given on July 6,” a statement from city officials read, according to 12news.

De Haan told TheDCNF that the city council never asked TST about “substantial community ties.”

“It’s disheartening when public officials can display such a flagrant disregard for the most foundational bedrock principles of Constitutional Law while acting upon their personal biases at the expense of their taxpayer base, who are ultimately left to pay the legal costs for the ignorance of their Mayor and City Council,” TST co-founder Lucien Greaves said in the press release.

Follow Joshua Gill on Twitter

Send tips to

Freedom of Speech Isn’t Free
The Daily Caller News Foundation is working hard to balance out the biased American media. For as little as $3, you can help us. Make a one-time donation to support the quality, independent journalism of TheDCNF. We’re not dependent on commercial or political support and we do not accept any government funding.

All content created by the Daily Caller News Foundation, an independent and nonpartisan newswire service, is available without charge to any legitimate news publisher that can provide a large audience. All republished articles must include our logo, our reporter’s byline and their DCNF affiliation. For any questions about our guidelines or partnering with us, please contact