Cardinal Cupich Denies Accusation Of Collaborating With Wuerl To Subvert US Bishops’ Abuse Proposals

REUTERS/Charles Rex Arbogast/Pool

Daily Caller News Foundation logo
Joshua Gill Religion Reporter
Font Size:

Catholic Cardinal Blase Cupich denied allegations Sunday that he and Cardinal Donald Wuerl subverted the U.S. bishops’ conference’s proposals concerning abuse by discussing alternatives with Vatican officials in advance.

Wuerl and Cupich, the archbishop of Chicago, collaborated on a proposal for a system to have allegations of sexual abuse reported to and investigated by senior church officials as an alternative to the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops’ proposal to have a lay-led commission investigate allegations and report them to law enforcement, Catholic News Agency (CNA) reported Friday.

The report also said that Cupich and Wuerl presented their proposal to the Vatican’s Congregation for Bishops before the USCCB’s meeting in Baltimore on Nov. 12-14, but Cupich has since denied the report’s claims. (RELATED: Cardinal Cupich Claims Some Clerical Offenses Were Consensual Sex Between Adults And Should Be Handled Differently)

“The allegation is false. At no time prior to the Baltimore meeting did the two of us collaborate in developing, nor even talk about, an alternative plan,” Cupich told Crux Now.

A spokesman for the Archdiocese of Washington, D.C., said that while Wuerl had discussed such a proposal in general terms in the summer, he had not officially submitted a proposal to the Congregation for Bishops.

Bishop Blase Cupich, Pope Francis' first major appointment in the hierarchy of the U.S. Catholic Church, exits Holy Name Cathedral after his installation as the new archbishop in Chicago November 18, 2014. Cupich, 65, who is seen as a moderate, succeeds the more conservative Cardinal Francis George, 77, who is retiring. REUTERS/Andrew Nelles

Bishop Blase Cupich, Pope Francis’ first major appointment in the hierarchy of the U.S. Catholic Church, exits Holy Name Cathedral after his installation as the new archbishop in Chicago, Nov. 18, 2014. REUTERS/Andrew Nelles

That proposal did surface, however, during the USCCB’s meeting in Baltimore, written and championed by Cupich. Cupich presented the alternative proposal after the conference president, Cardinal Daniel DiNardo, announced that the Congregation for Bishops, on which both Wuerl and Cupich serve, had ordered the conference to delay voting to adopt their initial proposals until after a February meeting of bishops in Rome.

Under Cupich’s proposal, allegations against a bishop would be investigated and handled by a metropolitan archbishop, as opposed to an independent third party.

Cupich said that he finalized the proposal after hearing of the Vatican-ordered delay with the help of several bishops, including Archbishop Salvatore Cordileone of San Francisco and Archbishop Charles Chaput of Philadelphia. He claimed that he presented the draft of his proposal to about six bishops, including Wuerl, but that Wuerl offered no feedback.

Senior chancery officials from the Archdiocese of Washington described the proposal as “a mutual effort” between Wuerl and Cupich that they had presented to and discussed with the Congregation for Bishops weeks in advance of the conference meeting, CNA reported.

Cupich also opposed the conference’s initial proposal for an independent lay commission to oversee the investigation of sex abuse allegations on the grounds that he saw it as “outsourcing” ecclesial responsibilities.

Follow Joshua on Twitter
Send tips to

All content created by the Daily Caller News Foundation, an independent and nonpartisan newswire service, is available without charge to any legitimate news publisher that can provide a large audience. All republished articles must include our logo, our reporter’s byline and their DCNF affiliation. For any questions about our guidelines or partnering with us, please contact