How Fake News On The World’s Largest App Is Causing Vigilante Killings, And Could Impact The Indian Election
When Mohammad Azam’s lifeless body was found on the side of the road in the Bidar district nine months ago, authorities were left with few answers. It was another installment in a string of social media-induced killings, which have become a serious problem in India.
The 27-year-old and his friends were beaten to death by a 2,000-deep angry mob after false rumors circulated on WhatsApp falsely accusing the innocent travelers of being child-kidnappers. Both tech companies and governments have taken measures to limit the spread of viral lynch mobs, but the problem is growing, with authorities grasping for tools to combat the threat.
WhatsApp, the most popular messenger app in the world, deals with many of the same disinformation-related concerns as its parent company Facebook, but faces these issues on a much larger scale. The persistent problem ramps up around election time with heightened rumors and politically-motivated content. (RELATED: How ‘Fake News’ Texts About Child Abductors, Organ Harvesters Are Triggering Mob Violence In India)
With more than 815 million people registered to vote, the upcoming general election in India is projected to be the biggest democratic election in world history. The magnitude of the event adds pressure to an already dire situation.
The child kidnapping rumors that went viral through the messaging service have spurred mobs resulting in the lynching of 33 people since January 2017, according to Poynter. The Facebook subsidiary took to the press Feb. 6 to make it clear they intend to avoid a similar disaster in India’s upcoming election, set to begin April 11.
“We have engaged with political parties to explain our firm view that WhatsApp is not a broadcast platform and is not a place to send messages at scale,” spokesman Carl Woog told the media in New Delhi, according to CNN. “We will be banning accounts that engage in [suspicious] behavior.” The company took steps to limit the number of forwards allowed on the platform in January, in an effort to check the problem.
Nevertheless the app is highly susceptible to spam messaging because of the layout of the platform. The ability to create mass groups and forward content from group to group with the click of a button, without fact checks or labels, has led to the viral spread of false content that is nearly impossible to track back to its source.
Whereas investigations into the role of such campaigns in United States’ elections have focused largely on Russian-perpetrated interference, India’s problems come from within; political parties are among the biggest culprits of disinformation dissemination.
Party workers run scripts that analyze what users in political groups are saying, and then exploit those conversations through mass-distributed messages. The staffers then use public group invite links to circumvent WhatsApp’s spam detection software and overload their party groups, according to ET Prime.
One story that exploded onto the national scene through the app last year contained the now-infamous rumors regarding child kidnappings. Messages alleged that 500 people dressed as vagrants would be roaming the streets of one of India’s central regions looking for people to kill for their body parts, and that 400 child traffickers would be in town for a child-abducting campaign.
Playing off fears of abductions, the false reports prompted a series of brutal beatings and killings across the country, including the lynching of a 26-year-old construction worker. It only later surfaced that the rumored perpetrators were uninvolved, and the story was completely fake.
In order to combat such behavior, WhatsApp is now implementing AI technology to identify and delete spam accounts and label forwarded messages as unoriginal content. The new tools have assisted in the removal of over 6 million accounts globally throughout the last three months, according to WhatsApp spokesman Carl Woog. (RELATED: Co-Founder Of WhatsApp To Leave Facebook After Alleged Disagreements)
The platform has also met with the Elections Commission of India, and warned political parties that they will be blocked if they commit any infringement of the app’s regulations, including sending mass unsolicited messages.
While it may seem conceivable that Indian citizens could just disregard messages spread on the platform, the nature of communications in the South Asian nation makes that notion a near impossibility.
Self-censorship has skyrocketed in light of Hindu nationalists’ campaigns to eliminate “anti-national” discourse from mainstream media, and journalists have been killed for reporting information unfavorable to the governing administration, according to Reporters Without Borders.
Mobile social media services then become pivotal to the unfiltered communication of information; the only problem is that the information is not verified, and in many cases, is not verifiable by the average citizen. With many Indian citizens poorly educated and on the internet for the first time, it is an environment ripe for convincing disinformation.
While Americans spend an average of 18 percent of their daily mobile internet time on the trio of major Facebook-owned social media apps Facebook, WhatsApp and Instagram, Indians spend a whopping 38 percent of their daily mobile internet time on such services, according to The Times of India. And while fake news has arguably been used to impact American politics, fake news in India can be deadly.
Some Indian officials, such as Vishwas Pandhare, the superintendent of police that rose to the top post in the wake of last year’s WhatsApp-related killings, believe the app is a matter of life and death.
“People in India can live without oxygen,” he told Wired. “But without WhatsApp, they will die.”
While Instagram and Facebook may not face the same threat levels in the upcoming campaign cycle as WhatsApp, they are still a big part of the Indian social media landscape, and are preparing for the election in a similar manner.
“Instagram and Facebook teams work together to identify and disrupt information operations on our platforms,” an Instagram representative told The Daily Caller in a statement.
“Information operations are when sophisticated threat actors run coordinated efforts to mislead and manipulate the public. As part of these efforts, we are in regular contact with law enforcement, outside experts and other companies around the world.”
Some experts are skeptical as to whether these measures will effectively address the problem, or whether the problem can be fixed by digital stopgaps alone.
“These are like Band-Aids,” said Dr. Kalyani Chadha, Associate Professor at the University of Maryland and co-founder of the Journalism Interactive Conference. “In India, the biggest problem is scale.”
Information can go viral within seconds on WhatsApp, explained Chadha. Groups can house up to 256 members, and if each forward a post to just five other groups, thousands of people will have seen information before any sort of fact-check has occurred.
The messages sent through private groups are not accessible by the public, which increases the difficulty of combating false information. “How do you fight something that you cannot really see?” she asked.
The false messages being spread in India feed into a deep-rooted distrust of the mainstream media, and often play off of preexisting conspiracies.
In the wake of a suicide bombing terrorist attack in northern India last month, a picture began circulating of politician Rahul Gandhi standing next to the bomber. Those who study photoshopped images would notice the image was likely doctored, but for many experiencing social media and internet for the first time, it seemed legitimate.
Within 24 hours of the attack, the fabricated picture had already spread like wildfire, with WhatsApp serving as the primary vehicle for its transmission.
The photo was not an isolated episode. False content poured through the messaging service, with several journalism agencies even picking up on and tweeting out a fabricated image of the bomber in combat gear.
Indian fact-checking project Boom Live was hard at work debunking such erroneous content, but distrust in the political system had already been amplified.
While India exhibits the most extreme example of disinformation in Asia, it is certainly not alone in fighting the phenomenon.
Chat apps are a facilitator of election-interfering disinformation in South Korea as well, where the government’s spy agency admitted to conducting calculated psychological cyberwarfare to influence the results of the 2012 election.
Military members in Myanmar published a book last year that included three fabricated images and false content in an effort to reshape public perception of the genocide of a domestic ethnic group that the UN has labeled as genocide, according to The Guardian.
Efforts to circumvent these disinformation campaigns have been on the rise as well.
The Association of Southeast Asian Nations convened to address the issue and compile a report detailing the framework for countering disinformation in May 2018, with a focus on education and awareness, community participation, detection and response and norms and guidelines, according to the Diplomat.
Indonesia recently established a National Cyber and Encryption Agency to combat fake news spread through social media, which has already begun arresting perpetrators and blocking accounts that deliberately spread fake content.
Now with WhatsApp and the Elections Commission of India working together, the country is poised for what will be perhaps the biggest test for disinformation prevention the region has ever experienced. With all eyes on the messaging service, the world’s largest democracy will head to the polls next week to choose their Prime Minister.
It is time to see if those Band-Aids can fix the wound.