EXCLUSIVE: Knights Of Columbus Faces Accusations Of Self-Dealing Amid Insurance Fraud Lawsuit

Photo by Mark Wilson/Getty Images

Amber Athey Podcast Columnist
Font Size:
  • The Knights of Columbus entered into a contract with a lobbying firm that ensured their Supreme Knight’s son, Carl Anderson, became the Catholic organization’s chief lobbyist
  • The contract gave more money for less work than under previous deals made by the Knights of Columbus
  • The Knights of Columbus is also currently embroiled in a major contract dispute lawsuit involving alleged insurance fraud 

The Knights of Columbus (KofC) gave a lucrative lobbying contract to a firm that employed Supreme Knight Carl Anderson’s son in 2017, leading the younger Anderson to become the chief lobbyist for the organization, according to disclosure forms.

KofC entered into the lobbying contract with Van Scoyoc Associates, a government affairs firm that employs Anderson’s son, also named Carl Anderson, according to a review of lobbying records by the Daily Caller. Under the contract, Van Scoyoc received more money for far less lobbying work than in other similar deals made by KofC. Anderson’s son was also listed on the lobbying records as being the primary lobbyist for the organization.

As the Supreme Knight of the KofC, the elder Anderson serves as the chief executive officer and chairman of the board.

Dr. Craig Holman, a government affairs lobbyist with Public Citizen, said that the lobbying deal raises ethical issues regarding self-dealing and nepotism.

“The very large imbalance of payments to the lobbying firms reeks of nepotism and is ethically problematic – but it is a problem borne solely by the Knights of Columbus,” Holman told the Caller. “Both lobbying firms are top-notch businesses, complete with insider connections that make their lobbying services equally valuable. Paying one firm more than double the other for services rendered strongly suggests that the family connection was the deciding factor.”

Members of the Knights of Columbus salute at the playing of the US National Anthem during the National Park Service and the National Columbus Celebration Association’s 96th annual Christopher Columbus wreath laying ceremony 08 October 2007 at the Christopher Columbus Statue in Columbus Plaza at Union Station in Washington, DC. (Photo credit: TIM SLOAN/AFP/Getty Images)

KofC, the world’s largest Catholic fraternal service organization, has recently dealt with partisan attacks from Democrats, who have suggested that membership in the organization disqualifies judicial nominees from office. However, outside of its status as a major source of religious charity, the organization is also now facing allegations of fraud and self-dealing. (RELATED: Senate Confirms Judicial Nominee  Pressed On Knights Of Columbus Membership)

BuzzFeed News reported last week that KofC is currently embroiled in a lawsuit that claims the organization artificially inflated its membership numbers to make itself more attractive to insurance companies. KofC then terminated its contract with an IT firm whose manager discovered the alleged insurance fraud, the suit argues.

The new details about KofC’s lobbying activities reveals another situation which should concern members of the organization, Holman said.

KofC first contracted with Van Scoyoc in February 2017 and paid the firm $100,000 over the next year, even though the firm only completed six months of lobbying work. Under a similar year-long deal made by KofC with QGA Public Affairs in 2015, KofC paid $80,000 for a full year’s worth of lobbying work.

The details of each deal are broken down as follows:

Knights of Columbus & Van Scoyoc

Q1 2017: KofC paid $10,000. No lobbying reported.

Q2 2017: KofC paid $30,000. Carl Anderson (son) lobbied on judicial nominations, health care reform, and USAID.

Q3 2017: KofC paid $20,000. Carl Anderson (son) lobbied on judicial nominations and USAID.

Q4 2017: KofC paid $30,000. No lobbying reported.

Q1 2018: KofC paid $10,000. No lobbying reported.

Knights of Columbus & QGA Public Affairs

Q1 2015: KofC paid $20,000. Lobbying done on appropriations bills.

Q2 2015: KofC paid $20,000. Lobbying done on appropriations bills and religious freedom issues.

Q3 2015: KofC paid $20,000. Lobbying done on appropriations bills and religious freedom issues.

Q4 2015: KofC paid $20,000. Lobbying done on appropriations bills and religious freedom issues.

The disclosures thus indicate that QGA Public Affairs received less money for more lobbying work when compared to the lobbying contract involving Anderson’s son.

Holman noted that the lobbying arrangements would not violate public ethic laws because of KofC’s standing as a private religious institution, but flagged it as an area of ethical concern.

“KofC is not a governmental entity, it is a private religious fraternal organization, so the laws and ethics rules that govern public entities do not apply in this case. This is an issue that members of the Knights of Columbus should be concerned about, but it is not an ethics transgression that violates public laws,” Holman said.

Sources familiar with the situation said that KofC executives are undermining the reputation of the organization’s members, who are known for donating millions of dollars and significant time to charity each year.

The Knights of Columbus did not respond to a request for comment.

UPDATE (August 29, 2019; 3:05 pm):

Kathleen Blomquist, a spokesperson for the Knights of Columbus, issued the following statement in response to the Daily Caller’s reporting:

“The Knights of Columbus has consistently worked to ensure that tax reform efforts do not harm non-profit fraternal benefits societies, and we retained Van Scoyoc Associates, a top lobbying firm, to support those efforts. Based on their success, the Knights of Columbus engaged the firm on a number of other issues, as well, including judicial nominations, health care reform, religious liberty and the issue of persecuted religious minorities in the Middle East. Over the past five years, the Knights have spent more than $25 million aiding to help those victims. With the firm’s assistance, the Knights worked with key members of Congress to successfully pass the Iraq and Syria Genocide Relief and Accountability Act of 2018 which was signed into law on December 11th. The Knights of Columbus have been and will continue to be fully transparent in our public disclosures.”