Big Tent Ideas

SHEFFIELD: Gavin Newsom Is Turning California Into A Third World State

erod Harris/Getty Images for Vox Media

Daily Caller News Foundation logo
Carrie Sheffield Carrie Sheffield is a contributor for Daily Caller. She earned a master’s in public policy from Harvard University, concentrating in business policy. She completed a Fulbright fellowship in Berlin and served as Warren Brookes Journalism Fellow at Competitive Enterprise Institute.
Font Size:

Declining population for the first time in its existence, rising violent crime rates, soaring homelessness, the highest gas prices in the country, companies leaving in droves – California’s future is withering away.

The disturbing headlines keep churning out of the Golden State: “Suspects arrested for stealing guns from California home of Rep. Karen Bass,” “140+ arrested in massive California child sex crimes sweep,”Santa Barbara County Reports Highest Murder Rate Since 2015,” and “antisemitic hate as crimes at an all-time high in CA.”

It’s no wonder then that Gov. Gavin Newsom himself has referred to part of his own jurisdiction as “a scene from ‘a Third World country.’” (RELATED: LIEBERMAN: A Little-Known UN Treaty Is A Raw Deal For America And The Senate Can’t Wait To Pass It)

Nonprofit California Forward reported earlier this year that “In terms of Education, another pillar of prosperity that tracks performance across the different stages of education, utilizing indicators like early childhood education and graduation rates, California is broadly similar to Latvia, the small country of 1.9 million in the former Soviet Bloc,” yet “Latvia has a GDP per capita of 17,619 or 22% of California.”

At the National Conservatism Conference in Miami (aka NatCon), tech titan Peter Thiel gave a withering, spot-on analogy comparing the striking similarities between California and Saudi Arabia. Both are subsidized heavily by “insane cash flows” of their main industries — oil for the Arab “Magic Kingdom” and tech for The Golden State.

“The way I would summarize the California framing,” said Thiel, a longtime resident of San Francisco and, since 2018, Los Angeles, “It’s roughly somewhere in between. It’s not as good as Norway. We’re not as bad as Equatorial Guinea. You should think of it basically roughly on par with Saudi Arabia.”

The billionaire tech investor, who said he recently bought a house in Miami that’s doubled in value since 2020, said massive subsidies enable an expansive, inefficient, bureaucratic class that crowds out poorer people by driving up real estate prices.

Indeed, even the liberal New York Times noted the hypocritical housing policies of California, which effectively zones out middle class families by overregulating building permits and denying multifamily housing developments.

Thiel said both California and Saudi Arabia have their own form of extreme religion — strict Islamic Wahhabism (which restricts women’s rights, for example) with the Saudis and liberal, orthodox wokeism for Californians. But he said most of the bureaucratic machines that run these cultural behemoths are “something like 20% true and 80%” convenient man-behind-the-curtain manipulation.

“It’s just sort of the Saudi prince bringing alcohol into the country or Gavin Newsom having dinner with friends at the French Laundry,” Thiel said. “That’s actually in some ways reassuring because it shows that you don’t really believe the Wahhabi or the woke nonsense, even though it sort of is part of the ideology …We should not confuse it as the main thing that’s going on.”

Thiel said while it’s easy to poke fun at the excesses of California’s terrible policies, he cautioned that Republicans shouldn’t just use “nihilistic negation” of these policies — wokeness, soft-on-crime, terrible energy policy and business regulations — without offering their own positive vision.

“We’re leaning way too far into the nihilistic negation,” Thiel said. “We don’t like the woke stuff, all of that’s true, but it’s not necessarily the way we get back to growth.”

Later at NatCon, Gov. Ron DeSantis from Florida (who is welcoming record numbers of wealthy California refugees) offered that positive vision.

In an embattled House and Senate map, Thiel’s wise words hold true: conservatism is William F. Buckley’s man standing athwart history yelling “Stop!” but that’s not enough.

We need a roadmap to restore California’s economy, protect working class jobs from destructive regulation, tamp down inflation, protect our Southern border, and empower parents with school choice that rewards excellence for students.

Carrie Sheffield is the Tony Blankley Fellow for American Exceptionalism at The Steamboat Institute.

The views and opinions expressed in this commentary are those of the author and do not reflect the official position of the Daily Caller News Foundation.

All content created by the Daily Caller News Foundation, an independent and nonpartisan newswire service, is available without charge to any legitimate news publisher that can provide a large audience. All republished articles must include our logo, our reporter’s byline and their DCNF affiliation. For any questions about our guidelines or partnering with us, please contact