Investigative Group

Exclusive: This Congressman Explains How Environmental Regulations Are Making Border Patrol’s Job A Lot Harder

Shutterstock/Michael Dechev

Daily Caller News Foundation logo
Ethan Barton Editor in Chief
Font Size:
  • Congressman Bruce Westerman recently visited the southern border
  • The Arkansas Republican says environmental regulations are preventing border agents from stopping smugglers
  • A border wall wouldn’t eliminate a need for Border Patrol to bypass environmental regulations in protected areas, he says

Environmental regulations are inhibiting Border Patrol agents from effectively stopping human and drug smugglers at the southern border, a congressional subcommittee chairman who recently visited the area told The Daily Caller News Foundation Wednesday.

Environmental regulations prevent Border Patrol from entering protected lands in vehicles, from building roads to access wilderness areas, and from filling tunnels cartels use to smuggle drugs, agents told Rep. Bruce Westerman, who chairs the House Committee on Natural Resources’ Oversight Investigations subcommittee.

“We’re certainly handicapping ourselves,” the Arkansas Republican told TheDCNF in an interview. Smugglers are “crossing the border illegally, there’s illegal drugs involved a lot of times. There’s all kinds of laws being broken and I don’t think they mind breaking the environmental rules, either.”

Westerman’s comments come a day before his subcommittee will hold a hearing on the topic.

In some cases, Border Patrol agents may know where illegal crossings occur or where smugglers or other operatives are located, but can’t reach them quickly, because the areas either can’t be accessed with vehicles or aren’t allowed to be. Instead, agents are often forced to intervene on foot or on horseback.

“You’re looking at a three- or four-hour response time,” Westerman told TheDCNF.

“The key word I walked away with was ‘access,'” he continued. “Our Border Patrol needs better access to the border. They’re somewhat hamstrung.’

In fact, more than 80 percent of the 262-mile section of the border around Tucson, Ariz. – one of the areas Westerman visited – is on federal land, according to the congressman. The Buenos Aires Wildlife Refuge is located to the south of Tucson and west of Nogales, Ariz. – the second area Westerman visited. There are also state preserves east of Nogales.

Westerman suggested building a road paralleling the border with occasional access points perpendicular. Agents need to apply with various environmental enforcement agencies if they want to build roads to access various areas along the border or fill in drug tunnels.

“The [approval] process can take from two weeks to up as much as five years to complete, depending on the complexity of the project,” U.S. Forest Service spokeswoman Babete Anderson told TheDCNF. “Examples such as moving a surveillance vehicle location may take a few weeks, where building a road in an inventory roadless area would take more time.”

But in one instance, it took 12 years to get approval to move a surveillance camera temporarily, a committee aide told TheDCNF.

Permits “could be held up in the process infinitely,” Westerman told TheDCNF.

“Even where you’ve got 18-foot tall-walls, you get tunnels dug under the border,” he continued. “You would think that when we find a tunnel we’d close it off and back fill it. But you might need to comply” with environmental regulations. (RELATED: Drug Smuggling Tunnels Skyrocketed After U.S. Tightened Border Security)

Westerman emphasized that even a border wall, like the one President Donald Trump has touted, wouldn’t eliminate the need for Border Patrol to bypass environmental regulations in protected areas.

“People will figure out how to cross a wall if there’s no deterrent on the other side of the wall,” Westerman told TheDCNF. “They figured out how to scale the 18-foot wall there in Nogales. If you’re out in the middle of nowhere, given enough time, you’ll figure out how to breach a wall.”

Making the areas accessible along the border would help Border Patrol prevent that.

Meanwhile, smugglers are leaving more than their footprints throughout protected areas.

“These remote areas are often being trashed and trampled by people illegally trafficking drugs and illegally trafficking humans across the border,” Westerman told TheDCNF. “I can tell you that they don’t give a flip about any of the other environmental regulations.”

Trash left by illegal entrants. (Photo: House Committee on Natural Resources, Subcommittee on Oversight and Investigations)

Trash left by illegal entrants. (Photo: House Committee on Natural Resources, Subcommittee on Oversight and Investigations)

Illegal immigration and drug smuggling across the border significantly harm wilderness areas and endangered species, TheDCNF previously reported.

Regardless, smugglers are exploiting Border Patrol’s inhibition from environmental regulations. Scouts are placed on the U.S. side of the border in areas agents can’t access and help people illegally crossing avoid agents.

“I was taken aback that these scouts were operating on U.S. territory working for the drug cartels,” Westerman told TheDCNF. “That just shouldn’t be so. Border Patrol agents can’t move without the cartels knowing. They have that many people.”

Westerman also accompanied on agents on raids during his trip. One night, they pursued 14 people illegally crossing the border, but they split into groups, so agents were only able to apprehend five.

“Another night they caught a woman with 52 grams of brown heroin,” Westerman told TheDCNF. “And that’s just one spot. That makes you wonder how many drugs actually get across the border and how many people are getting across the border.”

He noted that Border Patrol agents in the area seized 196 pounds of fentanyl and 113 pounds of heroin just in recent months.

There’s a “massive flow of drugs at the border,” Westerman said. “Who knows how much they haven’t stopped.”

“My goal is to put policy in place that allows Border Patrol to do their job much better,” he continued. Westerman pointed out that legislation has already been introduced that addresses agents inability to access certain areas, but he hopes to add language that eases restricting to filling in drug tunnels.

Customs and Border Patrol declined to comment because of the pending litigation concerning the agency’s use of waivers to avoid environmental regulations surrounding Trump’s border wall. The Department of the Interior declined to comment because TheDCNF did not provide specific examples of environmental regulations inhibiting Border Patrol agents.

Follow Ethan on Twitter. Send tips to

Freedom of Speech Isn’t Free
The Daily Caller News Foundation is working hard to balance out the biased American media. For as little as $3, you can help us. Make a one-time donation to support the quality, independent journalism of TheDCNF. We’re not dependent on commercial or political support and we do not accept any government funding.

All content created by the Daily Caller News Foundation, an independent and nonpartisan newswire service, is available without charge to any legitimate news publisher that can provide a large audience. All republished articles must include our logo, our reporter’s byline and their DCNF affiliation. For any questions about our guidelines or partnering with us, please contact