Florida City Uses Music To Deter Homeless — Advocates Call It Torture

Tero Vesalainen

Daily Caller News Foundation logo
Kyle Hooten Contributor
Font Size:

Authorities in West Palm Beach, Florida are using children’s music to deter the homeless from setting up camp in a city-owned park.

West Palm Beach Lake Pavilion is a city-owned park and event venue frequently used by the homeless as a place to sleep. City officials are now playing the children’s songs “Baby Shark” and “Raining Tacos” in the park to annoy homeless campers, preventing them from sleeping, according to the Palm Beach Post.

West Palm Beach Lake Pavilion. (Google Maps)

Seen here is the Palm Beach Lake Pavilion. (Google Maps)

“Legally morally ethically and even fiscally, any way you look at it, this [music] is not the right approach to this [homelessness] problem,” said Eric Tars, legal director at National Law Center on Homelessness & Poverty told The Daily Caller. (RELATED: Homelessness In San Francisco Bay Area Has Gone Amok As Officials Scramble For Answers)

“Sleep deprivation has been condemned as torture or at a minimum cruel, inhuman degrading treatment,” continued Tars. “It was condemned when they were playing loud rock music in Guantanamo or in Abu Ghraib to disrupt the detainees’ sleep patterns, and now we’re doing it to citizens,” he added.

“What we have is a situation where people, because of this narrative of the American work ethic… people assume that if somebody is homeless it’s because of some individual fault, some individual choices that they made, when really its the systemic choices that we’re all responsible for that are much more responsible for that person being [homeless],” Tars added.

The city states that it designed the pavilion as a place to host events, and that having homeless campers sleeping in the space makes it hard to rent out.

“People are paying a lot of money to use the facility,” a city spokesperson told the Palm Post. “Thousands of dollars. We want to make sure people paying this money had a facility that was clean and open and continue to use it in the future.”

The city claims that having full use of the pavilion, unimpeded by the homeless, will generate $240,000 in event fee revenue, according to the Palm Post.

So far, some locals have not reported hearing any music.

“I went out there and actually, I don’t know anything about Baby Shark being played,” a manager at E.R. Bradley’s Saloon told The Caller. Bradley’s is located on Lake Pavilion.

“It’s [homelessness] a problem and I think everyone knows it,” the manager said. When asked how she’d feel if the music were to play, the manager responded, “I think it’s great, if that’s what it takes, then that’s great.”

All content created by the Daily Caller News Foundation, an independent and nonpartisan newswire service, is available without charge to any legitimate news publisher that can provide a large audience. All republished articles must include our logo, our reporter’s byline and their DCNF affiliation. For any questions about our guidelines or partnering with us, please contact