Opinion

Abandoning Originalism Is How We Got “Separate But Equal” In The First Place

Reuters

Font Size:

One of the most pernicious attacks on constitutional originalism being advanced by opponents to Neil Gorsuch’s confirmation to the Supreme Court is the notion that it would have compelled the Supreme Court to uphold Plessy v. Ferguson, the notorious 1896 precedent sanctioning racial segregation in public facilities under the notion of “separate but equal,” instead of overturning it in Brown v. Board of Education. A brief review of the history shows the opposite to be the case.

The issue of segregation arose in the context of railroads decades before the Plessy Court faced that issue. Just a few years before there was a Fourteenth Amendment, the constitutional provision the Court was called to interpret, Congress passed a statute in 1863 extending a railroad into Washington, D.C., and requiring that “no person shall be excluded from the cars on account of color.” The railroad nonetheless separated otherwise equal train cars by race, and an African-American woman ejected from the white and forced to ride in the “colored” car sued. The Supreme Court unanimously ruled in her favor in 1873, rejecting an early “separate but equal” argument. While the case did not technically arise under the Fourteenth Amendment (ratified 1868), it did reflect the broad understanding of equality that characterized the Civil War-Reconstruction era.

In 1875, Congress passed a new Civil Rights Act that prohibited racial segregation in public accommodations and transportation, but the initial enthusiasm for racial equality was already giving way to growing public opposition to Reconstruction. The Supreme Court struck down the law in the Civil Rights Cases (1883) as exceeding the powers given to Congress under the Fourteenth Amendment—an odd conclusion to reach for a statute that passed with the affirmative votes of nearly all remaining members of the House or Senate who had voted for the Fourteenth Amendment. Thirteen years later, after former Confederate states were emboldened to pass laws requiring segregation in public facilities, the Court upheld them with its Plessy decision.

In both 1883 and 1896, it was not the Court’s majority, but the dissenting justice, John Harlan, whose argument invoked originalism. In his Civil Rights Cases dissent, Harlan expressed his “earnest conviction that the court has departed from the familiar rule requiring, in the interpretation of constitutional provisions, that full effect be given to the intent with which they were adopted.” Dissenting in Plessy, he reiterated that laws “must always have a reasonable construction. Sometimes they are to be construed strictly; sometimes liberally, in order to carry out the legislative will. But however construed, the intent of the legislature is to be respected.  .  .  .” (There’s a succinct axiom of originalist interpretation and how it differs from the mistake often made in equating it with knee-jerk strict constructionism.) That Harlan had the original meaning on his side was corroborated by an 1883 New York Times editorial that noted of his dissent, “The tendency during the war period was toward the construction he [Harlan] favors. Since then a reaction has set in….”

The story of the retreat from Reconstruction and the accompanying wane of the national zeal for equality is not widely remembered, but it illustrates a fundamental problem for non-originalists: The belief that the Constitution should change with the times enabled the injustice sanctioned by Plessy in the first place.

Frank Scaturro served as Counsel for the Constitution on the staff of the Senate Judiciary Committee between 2005 and 2009, in which capacity he worked on the nominations of John Roberts and Samuel Alito to the Supreme Court and Neil Gorsuch to the Tenth Circuit. He is the author of, among other titles, The Supreme Court’s Retreat from Reconstruction (Greenwood Press, 2000). Follow him on Twitter.

PREMIUM ARTICLE: Subscribe To Keep Reading

Sign up

By subscribing you agree to our Terms of Use

You're signed up!

Sign up

By subscribing you agree to our Terms of Use

You're signed up!
Sign up

By subscribing you agree to our Terms of Use

You're signed up!

Sign up

By subscribing you agree to our Terms of Use

You're signed up!
Sign up

By subscribing you agree to our Terms of Use

You're signed up!

Sign Up

By subscribing you agree to our Terms of Use

You're signed up!
Sign up

By subscribing you agree to our Terms of Use

You're signed up!
Sign up

By subscribing you agree to our Terms of Use

You're signed up!
BENEFITS READERS PASS PATRIOTS FOUNDERS
Daily and Breaking Newsletters
Daily Caller Shows
Ad Free Experience
Exclusive Articles
Custom Newsletters
Editor Daily Rundown
Behind The Scenes Coverage
Award Winning Documentaries
Patriot War Room
Patriot Live Chat
Exclusive Events
Gold Membership Card
Tucker Mug

What does Founders Club include?

Tucker Mug and Membership Card
Founders

Readers,

Instead of sucking up to the political and corporate powers that dominate America, The Daily Caller is fighting for you — our readers. We humbly ask you to consider joining us in this fight.

Now that millions of readers are rejecting the increasingly biased and even corrupt corporate media and joining us daily, there are powerful forces lined up to stop us: the old guard of the news media hopes to marginalize us; the big corporate ad agencies want to deprive us of revenue and put us out of business; senators threaten to have our reporters arrested for asking simple questions; the big tech platforms want to limit our ability to communicate with you; and the political party establishments feel threatened by our independence.

We don't complain -- we can't stand complainers -- but we do call it how we see it. We have a fight on our hands, and it's intense. We need your help to smash through the big tech, big media and big government blockade.

We're the insurgent outsiders for a reason: our deep-dive investigations hold the powerful to account. Our original videos undermine their narratives on a daily basis. Even our insistence on having fun infuriates them -- because we won’t bend the knee to political correctness.

One reason we stand apart is because we are not afraid to say we love America. We love her with every fiber of our being, and we think she's worth saving from today’s craziness.

Help us save her.

A second reason we stand out is the sheer number of honest responsible reporters we have helped train. We have trained so many solid reporters that they now hold prominent positions at publications across the political spectrum. Hear a rare reasonable voice at a place like CNN? There’s a good chance they were trained at Daily Caller. Same goes for the numerous Daily Caller alumni dominating the news coverage at outlets such as Fox News, Newsmax, Daily Wire and many others.

Simply put, America needs solid reporters fighting to tell the truth or we will never have honest elections or a fair system. We are working tirelessly to make that happen and we are making a difference.

Since 2010, The Daily Caller has grown immensely. We're in the halls of Congress. We're in the Oval Office. And we're in up to 20 million homes every single month. That's 20 million Americans like you who are impossible to ignore.

We can overcome the forces lined up against all of us. This is an important mission but we can’t do it unless you — the everyday Americans forgotten by the establishment — have our back.

Please consider becoming a Daily Caller Patriot today, and help us keep doing work that holds politicians, corporations and other leaders accountable. Help us thumb our noses at political correctness. Help us train a new generation of news reporters who will actually tell the truth. And help us remind Americans everywhere that there are millions of us who remain clear-eyed about our country's greatness.

In return for membership, Daily Caller Patriots will be able to read The Daily Caller without any of the ads that we have long used to support our mission. We know the ads drive you crazy. They drive us crazy too. But we need revenue to keep the fight going. If you join us, we will cut out the ads for you and put every Lincoln-headed cent we earn into amplifying our voice, training even more solid reporters, and giving you the ad-free experience and lightning fast website you deserve.

Patriots will also be eligible for Patriots Only content, newsletters, chats and live events with our reporters and editors. It's simple: welcome us into your lives, and we'll welcome you into ours.

We can save America together.

Become a Daily Caller Patriot today.

Signature

Neil Patel