Opinion

KOTHARI: I Was In The Jungle Last Time We Landed On The Moon — There’s No Reason We Can’t Do It Again

(Shutterstock/Vadim Sadovski)

Dr. Ajay Kothari Contributor

I still remember — although details are somewhat cloudy now, the gist of it is still clear as bell — the night when my teen and toddler brother and sisters, my father, some workers on the farm and I sat around a fire, on a somewhat cold night, in the middle of a jungle, and with an occasional indication of a panther passing through the farm, listening to an old decrepit Phillips radio, battery operated as there was no electricity either. Television was still too far away and we were too poor to afford it even if it was not! It was the late 1960s in Western India, on my father’s farm, and we were all very excited. Yes, this is a true story.

We were trying very hard to listen, amid heavy static, to the live broadcast of a NASA capsule splash-landing in the ocean, after a journey around the moon. We were amazed and awestruck that NASA and the United States could send a craft hundreds of thousands of miles and still have it come back and land in a pre-designated, three-mile-radius area — and do that safely.

Our respect for what the U.S. could do, which was already fairly high, increased immensely. NASA was amazing, and it symbolized the United States for many around the world.

What a country, this America! What incredible people! It was hard to control the desire to come here, study aerospace, get a PhD, become a rocket scientist and work in this field.

The Soviet Union also conductd spaceflight but would announce its ventures after the fact, not to belittle what they achieved. Not so with the United States. I thought, “This is where the next stage of evolution of human beings is occurring” — an intellectual evolution. It was very exciting. It was very satisfying. It was transparent. And it was not just NASA. America at that time was also abuzz with many creative questions, with anti-war movement, counter-culture revolution and with people’s free right to pursue the sometimes unlikely answers.

Americans then, and more so the generation today, do not realize the immense amount of goodwill this created worldwide with great intangible benefits for years to come. When the Apollo 11 team visited India in 1969, people there received them with the largest audience ever in Azad Maidan till then. The American transparency made the whole world feel like “we did it, the whole humankind.”

What happened to that excitement, that spark, for humanity’s spread in the third dimension? It did go away but it may just be coming back. Exactly fifty years later, we have a chance to build a virtual railroad now to Moon, Mars and beyond.

Building a railroad line that connected the United States coast-to-coast was advocated in 1832 when Dr. Hartwell Carver published an article in the New York Courier & Enquirer advocating building a transcontinental railroad from Lake Michigan to Oregon. In 1847 he submitted to the U.S. Congress a “Proposal for a Charter to Build a Railroad from Lake Michigan to the Pacific Ocean,” seeking a congressional charter to support his idea. The First Transcontinental Railroad was soon built in 1863-69 in three sections, somewhat south of Carver’s proposal, from Omaha, Nebraska to Oakland, California using mostly the Asian American and Irish American labor — with numerous deaths and regrettably not even bestowing of any credit to them.

Exactly 100 years later and almost in same length of time, we built the pathway to moon with Apollo! Now, coincidently exactly 50 years later, the time now has come for us to build this railroad for moon, Mars and other destinations in the solar system with Americans of all genders, race, creed and religion participating and receiving credit when due, in a sense righting the wrong of 150 years ago. It can be done. It is ready to be executed. It is an exciting time in more ways than one. 

New developments of the last decade

If we combine the inspirational and technological aspects of our past with the recent discoveries, it becomes all the more clear that this time we need to go there to do things. These include learning how to live in low gravity and no atmosphere but also extract one of the most important ingredients of life – water – the existence of which in large quantities, more than 600 million ton, was confirmed recently only. This water-ice that can be decomposed into rocket propellants potentially using solar energy becomes the most important aspect for going anywhere else in the solar system from the moon directly, with its smaller gravity well requiring much less fuel to get out. This combined with the experience gained there would make Mars, Europa and asteroids full of precious metals easier to visit. Surely this will take decades but we need to start somewhere. In this sense water-ice will prove to be more valuable to humanity than if gold were discovered on the moon!

We also today have the availability of reusable first stages of Falcon Heavy and soon the New Glenn with the potential for reducing the cost by a factor of five to eight times by docking several upper stages in orbit with these cheaper reusable rocket flights. With this paradigm shift we can even have hundreds of people living there, albeit for a few months at a time, working on “in situ resource utilization” (ISRU).

Today India’s Chandrayaan 2 lifted off for its voyage to the lunar south pole where the water-ice is the most abundant. China’s Chang’e 4 landed on the South Pole on Farside in January. Israel, Russia and Japan are to follow suit. Let us together have friendly competition with other countries as they will also land their folks on the moon and work towards ISRU.

We need to be there as soon as possible for the lunar water-ice resources, and this  administration has noticed that, which is a very good thing. This is the first time in a long time that an administration has been keenly interested in doing what our rocket scientists/engineers want. Yes, it is a challenge. Let us attack it with enthusiasm as we did 50 years ago — not pessimism.

And we went to the moon in under a decade in the 60s with less computer power than we now carry in the palm of our hands, with an iPhone or Android! And we cannot do this in less than five, especially with all Americans helping as equal partners? When again are we going to have this synergy of so many favorable factors at the same time culminating into a real possibility for us? Let us help NASA by creating the public support.

This time, we are going there to stay and work. It is not a redo of what we have already done. Been there, yes. Done that, no!

I hope the woman astronaut on Artemis this time will be the first to disembark on the lunar surface. This time I hope to hear the words “one small step for woman, one giant leap for womankind.”

Dr. Ajay Kothari is an aerospace engineer and president of Astrox Corporation.


The views and opinions expressed in this commentary are those of the author and do not reflect the official position of The Daily Caller.