Opinion

The Problem With The Supreme Court’s Hobby Lobby Decision

Ron Fein Legal Director, Free Speech For People
Font Size:

On June 30, the Supreme Court announced its decision in the Hobby Lobby and Conestoga Wood Specialties cases. The Court ruled that for-profit corporations have the right to a religious exemption from federal Affordable Care Act rules requiring insurance plans to cover birth control. The media coverage, like the demonstrations in front of the courthouse steps, has focused on the hot-button issues of birth control and abortion. But the decision goes much further.

The Court based its decision on the federal Religious Freedom Restoration Act, which sets a strict test for any federal law that burdens a “person’s” exercise of religion. But is a corporation a “person”?

Federal judges have held in recent decisions that corporations have free speech rights. In the infamous 2010 Citizens United v. Federal Election Commission decision, the Supreme Court said that corporations have the same freedom of speech right to spend money in political elections that flesh-and-blood people do. In a less-publicized 2011 decision, Sorrell v. IMS Health, the Court said that data-mining companies have a freedom of speech right to sell drug prescription records to drug companies for marketing purposes.

Now the Court claims that corporations exercise religion. But corporations are not people. They’re artificial legal entities. They were not “endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights,” as Thomas Jefferson put it in the Declaration of Independence. Rather, they’re useful economic structures created and controlled by state law.

This latest Supreme Court ruling is not about freedom, but power. The Supreme Court’s decision allows for-profit business corporations to impose their stockholders’ religious views on employees who may follow entirely different religions.

One of the Court’s problems is a failure of imagination. The justices look at the current landscape of corporate ownership, and the fact that no one ever thought to raise claims for corporate religious exemptions before, and conclude that the issue is narrow. But reduced employee insurance costs will give a slight market edge in a low-margin business. If a small group of evangelical investors, or Saudi princes, can buy a company and then cut costs on health insurance by raising religious objections to rules that their competitors must follow, they will. And if a Saudi billionaire objects to paying any health insurance costs for women who work outside the home, then he can really cut costs.

And it’s not just about insurance. Most religions object to something, and the Court’s ruling provides a new avenue for corporate challenges to any federal law whatsoever. The Fatima Center, a radical Catholic traditionalist group, holds that climate change is a vast Satanic hoax. Corporate investors who follow its teachings might not want their companies to comply with greenhouse gas emissions rules — and based on Monday’s Supreme Court ruling, they might have a claim for a religious exemption.

Those who agree with Hobby Lobby claim that the Court has granted religious exemptions to incorporated congregations before, and the difference between for-profit and nonprofit corporations isn’t important. But that’s silly. The truth is, nonprofit corporations don’t themselves have religious rights either. Rather, a religious organization (like a church, synagogue, or mosque) can come into court to represent the religious rights of its members. And we assume that a congregation or religious nonprofit organization doesn’t have a financial motive for creatively inflating its claims for exemptions, precisely because it’s a nonprofit.

But business corporations aren’t congregations, and now that millions or billions in saved costs are potentially at stake, the number and scope of potential corporate religious claims is limited only by the creativity of business in finding a slight market edge. This doesn’t mean that corporate investors will raise insincere claims (though that will happen too). Rather, entirely sincere religious corporate investors will gain a business advantage, courtesy of the Supreme Court, by claiming religious exemptions that they never thought of before.

All this illustrates the folly of “corporate religion.” Some business corporations will use this ruling to squeeze employees and competitors. Others will use it as license to discriminate. And some will do neither. But one thing is certain: allowing business corporations to claim religious exemptions means less freedom for ordinary Americans.

Since this ruling is based on a law that Congress passed, Congress can fix the problem by closing this corporate loophole. Corporations aren’t people, but real people will suffer until this is fixed.

Ron Fein is the Legal Director for Free Speech For People. He submitted an amicus brief to the Supreme Court in the Conestoga Wood Specialties Corporation case.

PREMIUM ARTICLE: Subscribe To Keep Reading

Sign up

By subscribing you agree to our Terms of Use

You're signed up!

Sign up

By subscribing you agree to our Terms of Use

You're signed up!
Sign up

By subscribing you agree to our Terms of Use

You're signed up!

Sign up

By subscribing you agree to our Terms of Use

You're signed up!
Sign up

By subscribing you agree to our Terms of Use

You're signed up!

Sign Up

By subscribing you agree to our Terms of Use

You're signed up!
Sign up

By subscribing you agree to our Terms of Use

You're signed up!
Sign up

By subscribing you agree to our Terms of Use

You're signed up!
BENEFITS READERS PASS PATRIOTS FOUNDERS
Daily and Breaking Newsletters
Daily Caller Shows
Ad Free Experience
Exclusive Articles
Custom Newsletters
Editor Daily Rundown
Behind The Scenes Coverage
Award Winning Documentaries
Patriot War Room
Patriot Live Chat
Exclusive Events
Gold Membership Card
Tucker Mug

What does Founders Club include?

Tucker Mug and Membership Card
Founders

Readers,

Instead of sucking up to the political and corporate powers that dominate America, The Daily Caller is fighting for you — our readers. We humbly ask you to consider joining us in this fight.

Now that millions of readers are rejecting the increasingly biased and even corrupt corporate media and joining us daily, there are powerful forces lined up to stop us: the old guard of the news media hopes to marginalize us; the big corporate ad agencies want to deprive us of revenue and put us out of business; senators threaten to have our reporters arrested for asking simple questions; the big tech platforms want to limit our ability to communicate with you; and the political party establishments feel threatened by our independence.

We don't complain -- we can't stand complainers -- but we do call it how we see it. We have a fight on our hands, and it's intense. We need your help to smash through the big tech, big media and big government blockade.

We're the insurgent outsiders for a reason: our deep-dive investigations hold the powerful to account. Our original videos undermine their narratives on a daily basis. Even our insistence on having fun infuriates them -- because we won’t bend the knee to political correctness.

One reason we stand apart is because we are not afraid to say we love America. We love her with every fiber of our being, and we think she's worth saving from today’s craziness.

Help us save her.

A second reason we stand out is the sheer number of honest responsible reporters we have helped train. We have trained so many solid reporters that they now hold prominent positions at publications across the political spectrum. Hear a rare reasonable voice at a place like CNN? There’s a good chance they were trained at Daily Caller. Same goes for the numerous Daily Caller alumni dominating the news coverage at outlets such as Fox News, Newsmax, Daily Wire and many others.

Simply put, America needs solid reporters fighting to tell the truth or we will never have honest elections or a fair system. We are working tirelessly to make that happen and we are making a difference.

Since 2010, The Daily Caller has grown immensely. We're in the halls of Congress. We're in the Oval Office. And we're in up to 20 million homes every single month. That's 20 million Americans like you who are impossible to ignore.

We can overcome the forces lined up against all of us. This is an important mission but we can’t do it unless you — the everyday Americans forgotten by the establishment — have our back.

Please consider becoming a Daily Caller Patriot today, and help us keep doing work that holds politicians, corporations and other leaders accountable. Help us thumb our noses at political correctness. Help us train a new generation of news reporters who will actually tell the truth. And help us remind Americans everywhere that there are millions of us who remain clear-eyed about our country's greatness.

In return for membership, Daily Caller Patriots will be able to read The Daily Caller without any of the ads that we have long used to support our mission. We know the ads drive you crazy. They drive us crazy too. But we need revenue to keep the fight going. If you join us, we will cut out the ads for you and put every Lincoln-headed cent we earn into amplifying our voice, training even more solid reporters, and giving you the ad-free experience and lightning fast website you deserve.

Patriots will also be eligible for Patriots Only content, newsletters, chats and live events with our reporters and editors. It's simple: welcome us into your lives, and we'll welcome you into ours.

We can save America together.

Become a Daily Caller Patriot today.

Signature

Neil Patel