Ginni Thomas

Political Scientist: Islam Is Incompatible With America’s Founding

Daily Caller News Foundation logo
Ginni Thomas Contributor
Font Size:

Muslim intolerance for non-believers is America’s coming problem with Islam, according to one political scientist.

For Muslims in America, “you’ve got a theological, political problem that I think is incompatible with Western democracy” since they do not tolerate the religious liberty of others, says Matthew Spalding, associate vice president and dean of educational programs for Hillsdale College’s Kirby Center in Washington, D.C.

Spalding’s professional mission is to help remind Americans of their noble founding principles and what makes America exceptional in the history of mankind. Spalding received his doctorate from Claremont Graduate School and became a vice president at The Heritage Foundation until he was drawn to Hillsdale College’s Washington campus, the Kirby Center. Currently, Spalding is one of the most popular speakers on the topic of the conflict of visions battling to set America’s future.

Because of the long-standing battle by progressives throughout our culture and our government, America is now “at a crisis,” Spalding says. “We are at a new and problematic phase,” one that is “getting people increasingly concerned.”

Spalding says the choice we face is between a limited constitutional government that grants maximum liberty and opportunity to the people, allowing civil society to flourish apart from government, or a burgeoning active, modern administrative state that is sold as “progress” but is non-responsive to anyone but the political elites.

Interviewed in mid-December at Hillsdale’s Kirby Center in Washington, D.C., Spalding fears too many citizens are unfamiliar with what has set America apart and the stakes of this political battle.

Asked for the best criteria he would suggest for citizens to choose a new statesman for president in 2016, Spalding named two. He says the next leader should understand the nature of the crisis America is facing, and be able to lay out solutions and strategies for addressing that crisis. Spalding calls for a national dialogue on who we are, where we are going and how we will alter the course America is on.

Hillsdale College, which refuses federal subsidies because of unwanted federal interference, has been keenly aware of progressive meddling and government control of education. Spalding speaks of the elites as similar to a science fiction “blob” that won’t stop until it controls higher education, K-12 and now pre-school — reminding us that progressives since John Dewey have worked to control the formation of citizens.

With progressives now dominating our government and culture, Spalding believes in hindsight that the definitive cultural indicator progressives won was the erosion and collapse of traditional marriage and family. Progressives have been jealous of the power of families and religion, making them a longtime target of those who wish to have the government the arbiter of all rights, he says.

In this 29-minute exclusive video interview for The Daily Caller News Foundation, Spalding says — despite the name calling by the left — it is they who are pulling us back to a dark historical time before the American experiment granted rights and opportunities to the citizens, apart from kings and rulers.

He gives low grades to the Republican Congress that continues to grant excessive power to the growing administrative state that writes ever-more prescriptive regulations — regulations that are the proper prerogative of the legislative branch since they are most accountable to the citizens.

Instead, Congress has allowed its muscles to atrophy, Spalding says. The question will be how new leaders in Congress can turn the whole ship to restore the proper separation of powers to our government, he explains.

For more on Spalding see his best-selling book, “We Still Hold These Truths: Rediscovering Our Principles, Reclaiming Our Future,” and the Kirby Center. More on Hillsdale College can also be found here.

Mrs. Thomas does not necessarily support or endorse the products, services or positions promoted in any advertisement contained herein, and does not have control over or receive compensation from any advertiser.

All content created by the Daily Caller News Foundation, an independent and nonpartisan newswire service, is available without charge to any legitimate news publisher that can provide a large audience. All republished articles must include our logo, our reporter’s byline and their DCNF affiliation. For any questions about our guidelines or partnering with us, please contact