Opinion

The ‘fair share’ myth

Joseph F. Petros III Former Executive Editor, Notre Dame Journal of Law, Ethics & Public Policy
Font Size:

If President Obama is re-elected in November, it will be for one reason: the American people believe that the rich are not paying as big a percentage of their income in taxes as everyone else.

That will be a sad day, for America will have elected its leader based on a premise that is entirely false.

The president has deliberately framed his tax argument in terms of fairness, demanding that the rich simply pay their “fair share” and that Warren Buffett not be allowed a lower effective tax rate than his secretary. Republicans can learn a lot from what the president is saying. Indeed, the president’s rhetoric on taxes tells us a lot more about the American people than does the substance of his policies.

The American people want what President Obama preaches: fairness. Fairness is a fundamental American principle, and it still controls Americans’ moral compasses to this day. Americans believe that everyone should be equal before the law — but not necessarily equal in wealth. On the whole, Americans also believe that everyone is entitled to keep the fruits of his labor. Calls to penalize the wealthy or to redistribute income generally do not play well in America, and the president knows it. That is why the president cannot run on the true substance of his proposals, which demand that the rich contribute much more of their income than everyone else.

In order to win over the electorate, the president must convince Americans that the rich are benefiting from an unfair tax system — that they are currently paying a smaller percentage of their income than everyone else. So far, he has done a darn good job. He has taken advantage of the complexity of the tax code to mislead the American people on a subject they do not fully understand, and few in the Republican ranks have directly called him out on it.

Take the president’s assertion that, because of the lower tax rates on dividends and capital gains compared to most regular income rates, many wealthy people like Warren Buffett and Mitt Romney only pay an effective rate of 15% on their income, almost all of which comes from investments. This makes for a great talking point — but it is extremely misleading. The reason dividends and capital gains are taxed at a lower rate is because most of that income has already been taxed at the exorbitantly high corporate rate of 35%. Those corporate taxes do not show up on individual tax returns, but they are nevertheless taxes on shareholders’ investment income. When you combine the 35% tax on income at the corporate level with the additional 15% tax when that income is distributed to shareholders as either dividends or capital gains, the result is that investors are actually forking over about 44.75% of their investment income to the federal government.

If Republican candidates, presidential and congressional, want to gain any traction with the electorate this year, they must address this fairness myth head on. It is not sufficient to simply argue that increasing taxes on the wealthy will inhibit economic growth. By confining their response to this, Republicans are conceding the fairness issue to the president. Republicans should — and must — own the fairness argument.

Republicans should call the president’s bluff and propose a plan for tax reform that truly is fair. Here’s an idea: raise the rates on dividends and capital gains to parallel the regular income rates, but totally eliminate the corporate tax. Not only would this be good politics, but it would make perfect sense. It only makes sense to tax income when it is distributed to individuals because only individuals can consume and enjoy income. I can’t say that I’ve ever seen a corporation eating out at a restaurant or taking in a movie. Corporate income is either put back into the business for business purposes or distributed to individual shareholders, who in turn enjoy the fruits of their investments.

Eliminating the corporate tax would also help solve another of the Democrats’ common gripes: that corporations are making large profits but refusing to use those profits to create jobs. It would give corporations a huge incentive to reinvest their profits in further growth, and it would give investors a reason to prefer long-term investment over short-term payoff.

Combine this proposal with an overall flattening of income rates and an elimination of loopholes, and Republicans will have a winning argument in 2012. It is no coincidence that candidates have been most successful this election season when they have talked about true tax reform (remember 9-9-9 fever?). Americans are craving for fairness, simplicity and honesty when it comes to tax policy. Republicans must stop cowering in the shadow of the president’s “fair share” rhetoric and take the time to explain the truth to the American people.

The president cannot be allowed to win re-election based on a false premise. That, in fact, would be unfair.

Joseph Petros is an associate at the law firm of Warren and Young PLL in Ashtabula, Ohio. He is a graduate of the University of Notre Dame and the University of Notre Dame Law School, where he served as executive editor of the Notre Dame Journal of Law, Ethics & Public Policy.

PREMIUM ARTICLE: Subscribe To Keep Reading

Sign up

By subscribing you agree to our Terms of Use

You're signed up!

Sign up

By subscribing you agree to our Terms of Use

You're signed up!
Sign up

By subscribing you agree to our Terms of Use

You're signed up!

Sign up

By subscribing you agree to our Terms of Use

You're signed up!
Sign up

By subscribing you agree to our Terms of Use

You're signed up!

Sign Up

By subscribing you agree to our Terms of Use

You're signed up!
Sign up

By subscribing you agree to our Terms of Use

You're signed up!
Sign up

By subscribing you agree to our Terms of Use

You're signed up!
BENEFITS READERS PASS PATRIOTS FOUNDERS
Daily and Breaking Newsletters
Daily Caller Shows
Ad Free Experience
Exclusive Articles
Custom Newsletters
Editor Daily Rundown
Behind The Scenes Coverage
Award Winning Documentaries
Patriot War Room
Patriot Live Chat
Exclusive Events
Gold Membership Card
Tucker Mug

What does Founders Club include?

Tucker Mug and Membership Card
Founders

Readers,

Instead of sucking up to the political and corporate powers that dominate America, The Daily Caller is fighting for you — our readers. We humbly ask you to consider joining us in this fight.

Now that millions of readers are rejecting the increasingly biased and even corrupt corporate media and joining us daily, there are powerful forces lined up to stop us: the old guard of the news media hopes to marginalize us; the big corporate ad agencies want to deprive us of revenue and put us out of business; senators threaten to have our reporters arrested for asking simple questions; the big tech platforms want to limit our ability to communicate with you; and the political party establishments feel threatened by our independence.

We don't complain -- we can't stand complainers -- but we do call it how we see it. We have a fight on our hands, and it's intense. We need your help to smash through the big tech, big media and big government blockade.

We're the insurgent outsiders for a reason: our deep-dive investigations hold the powerful to account. Our original videos undermine their narratives on a daily basis. Even our insistence on having fun infuriates them -- because we won’t bend the knee to political correctness.

One reason we stand apart is because we are not afraid to say we love America. We love her with every fiber of our being, and we think she's worth saving from today’s craziness.

Help us save her.

A second reason we stand out is the sheer number of honest responsible reporters we have helped train. We have trained so many solid reporters that they now hold prominent positions at publications across the political spectrum. Hear a rare reasonable voice at a place like CNN? There’s a good chance they were trained at Daily Caller. Same goes for the numerous Daily Caller alumni dominating the news coverage at outlets such as Fox News, Newsmax, Daily Wire and many others.

Simply put, America needs solid reporters fighting to tell the truth or we will never have honest elections or a fair system. We are working tirelessly to make that happen and we are making a difference.

Since 2010, The Daily Caller has grown immensely. We're in the halls of Congress. We're in the Oval Office. And we're in up to 20 million homes every single month. That's 20 million Americans like you who are impossible to ignore.

We can overcome the forces lined up against all of us. This is an important mission but we can’t do it unless you — the everyday Americans forgotten by the establishment — have our back.

Please consider becoming a Daily Caller Patriot today, and help us keep doing work that holds politicians, corporations and other leaders accountable. Help us thumb our noses at political correctness. Help us train a new generation of news reporters who will actually tell the truth. And help us remind Americans everywhere that there are millions of us who remain clear-eyed about our country's greatness.

In return for membership, Daily Caller Patriots will be able to read The Daily Caller without any of the ads that we have long used to support our mission. We know the ads drive you crazy. They drive us crazy too. But we need revenue to keep the fight going. If you join us, we will cut out the ads for you and put every Lincoln-headed cent we earn into amplifying our voice, training even more solid reporters, and giving you the ad-free experience and lightning fast website you deserve.

Patriots will also be eligible for Patriots Only content, newsletters, chats and live events with our reporters and editors. It's simple: welcome us into your lives, and we'll welcome you into ours.

We can save America together.

Become a Daily Caller Patriot today.

Signature

Neil Patel