The Daily Caller

The Daily Caller

Skilled immigration: The new common ground in the reform debate

Photo of Alex Nowrasteh
Alex Nowrasteh
Immigration Policy Analyst, Cato Institute

On Monday, the government began accepting applications for the H-1B highly skilled worker visa program. This year’s 85,000 H-1B slots are expected to be gone by Friday.

The H-1B visa program allows highly skilled immigrants to work in the United States for up to six years with the option of applying for a green card. If industry experts, immigration attorneys, and government spokesmen are right and the annual H-1B cap is hit within a week of applications being made available, it will be the first time that has happened since 2008.

H-1Bs are a bellwether for the economy. As growth picks up, so do filings for H-1B applications. As unemployment skyrockets, filings for H-1B applications plummet. The high demand for these visas this year is a good omen for the economy, and hopefully for immigration reform efforts as well. Highly skilled immigrants are generally considered the “sugar” in any immigration reform efforts — they are used to “sweeten” the other controversial elements like legalization.

After all, highly skilled immigrants tend to speak English, and there’s little fear of them abusing welfare or committing crimes. Their children typically excel at school, are economically successful, and are more culturally integrated than their parents.

Even committed immigration skeptic Rep. Lamar Smith (R-Tex.) has sponsored a bill to increase the number of green cards for skilled immigrant workers educated in the U.S., saying: “In a global economy, we cannot afford to educate these foreign graduates in the U.S. and then send them back home to work for our competitors.”

The members of the Senate’s Gang of Eight — a bipartisan group of senators who are crafting an immigration reform bill — seem to agree that the U.S. should admit more high-skilled immigrants and appear to be using high-skilled immigration reform as a sweetener in negotiations over immigration reform more generally.

But even with growing support for high-skilled immigration, there remain critics. A recent New York Times op-ed by Ross Eisenbrey called “America’s Genius Glut” (no joke) argued that America has too many skilled people as it is, wages for those workers are falling, and unemployment is too high to justify allowing more skilled workers into the country.

On the contrary, average wages for H-1B workers have been increasing steadily since 2008 — by almost $6,000, according to data put together by Citizenship and Immigration Services. If American wages are stagnant, as Eisenbrey says, why are companies paying more for foreign workers today than they did just a few years ago?

The evidence that foreign skilled immigrants drive down American wages is scant.

Claims that they’re taking jobs away from Americans are also specious. Ninety-nine percent of new H-1B workers in 2011 had a bachelor’s degree or higher. The unemployment rate for similar American workers is 3.7 percent, lower than a year ago. That unemployment rate is also the lowest of all educational groups. Just over half of all H-1B workers work in the computer industry, where unemployment is under 4 percent.